Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

Between the Classroom and the Living Room: Social Gaps in Digital Skills Are Widening

AYO Production / Shutterstock

A new analysis by DIPF | Leibniz Institute for Research and Information in Education, Goethe University Frankfurt, and the University of Paderborn shows that social disparities in the digital skills of eighth-grade students have increased significantly over the past decade. According to the researchers, the trend is driven primarily by the cultural environment at home and the type of school students attend.

“Young people’s social background is increasingly shaping unequal levels of digital competence,” says Dr. Markus Lörz, lead author of the study, which recently published in the academic journal Computers & Education. “The cultural environment at home and the type of school attended have emerged as the central factors behind this digital inequality,” Lörz explains.

 

The Study

For the analysis, the research team – Dr. Markus Lörz and Prof. Dr. Birgit Becker (both from Goethe University Frankfurt), as well as Dr. Jan Niemann, Dr. Kerstin Drossel, and Prof. Dr. Birgit Eickelmann (all from the University of Paderborn) – examined German data from the “International Computer and Information Literacy Study” (ICILS) collected in 2013, 2018, and 2023. The study covered around 8,500 eighth-grade students and analyzed their computer and information literacy in relation to social background. The assessment focused on how critically, responsibly, and thoughtfully young people use digital technologies and information.

As part of the secondary analysis, the researchers investigated how students’ digital competencies developed between 2013 and 2023 across different social groups. Social background was measured using parents’ socio-economic status. The team also examined three additional factors: the digital home environment (such as access to devices, computer experience, and the use of digital tools for learning), the cultural home environment (measured by the number of books in the household), and the type of school attended (Gymnasium, comprehensive schools, and other school types). The researchers analyzed the extent to which these factors help explain social differences in digital competencies.

Findings

In 2013, the gap in digital competencies between students from more privileged and less privileged families stood at 43 points. By 2023, it had increased to 66 points. The analysis also showed that both the cultural learning environment at home and educational pathways differed markedly depending on students’ social background.

The researchers found not only that these learning conditions were strongly linked to the development of digital skills, but also that their influence has grown over time. In 2013, for example, students from households with more than 200 books scored 66 points higher than those from households with 25 books or fewer. By 2023, this gap had widened to 86 points. A similar trend emerged across school types: students attending a German Gymnasium outperformed students at other schools by 65 points in 2013, compared to an 85-point difference in 2023.

At the same time, the researchers stress that differences in home and school learning environments alone do not fully explain the rise in social inequalities. Even after accounting for these factors, disparities in digital skills continued to grow. The team suggests that the COVID-19 pandemic may have intensified these developments, as the sudden increase in the use of digital media particularly benefited students from more privileged households, who were generally better equipped to adapt.

Interpretation

According to the researchers, a new dimension of social inequality is emerging in the digital sphere. “Since the overall level of digital competence among students in Germany has declined over the period under review, the growing inequality is not primarily the result of some groups improving significantly,” Lörz says. “Rather, certain groups have fallen behind more sharply.” Reflecting on the influence of the cultural home environment and school type, the education researcher argues that “greater efforts are needed to counter the socially unequal distribution of students across different types of schools. Schools have a particular responsibility to compensate for the more challenging cultural learning conditions faced by children from families with lower socio-economic status.”

At the same time, the researchers note several limitations to the analysis. Measuring the cultural home learning environment solely through the number of books in a household and the school learning environment only through school type provides only a limited picture. In addition, the rapid rise of AI-driven technologies is not yet adequately reflected in the available data. The authors therefore emphasize the need for further research before more definitive conclusions can be drawn.
 

Editor: Dr. Dirk Frank, Press Officer/ Deputy Press Spokesperson, PR & Communications Office, Theodor-W.-Adorno-Platz 1, 60323 Frankfurt, Tel.: +49 (0)69/798-13753, [email protected]

Social Gaps in Digital Skills Are Widening