
Prof. Dr. Sandra Ciesek (2nd from left) during a panel discussion moderated by Volker Stollorz (Science Media Center, right) on the topic “COVID (Fake) News Then and Now,” with Dr. Cihan Çelik (Darmstadt University Hospital, left) and Prof. Dr. Constanze Rossmann (Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, second from right).
In early October, scientists from various disciplines gathered at the Berlin-Brandenburg Academy of Sciences and Humanities (BBAW) to discuss threats to science and democracy—ranging from COVID disinformation to illiberal government policies—and to develop counterstrategies. Questions for Frankfurt-based virologist Prof. Sandra Ciesek, a speaker and co-organizer of the symposium.
UniReport: Ms. Ciesek, the symposium you helped organize was titled “Science for Democracy.” Do you think this clear commitment from the scientific community has now become necessary?
Sandra Ciesek: Yes, and I believe this commitment is more important today than ever before. For a long time, we took it for granted that academic freedom is permanently safeguarded in a liberal democracy. Developments in other countries show just how vulnerable it can be. Science needs independent institutions, reliable funding, and, above all, the freedom to publish and publicly defend even uncomfortable findings. “Science for Democracy” does not mean, however, that science should become partisan. It must remain independent, even from the political positions that individual scientists personally hold. It can and must, however, advocate for the conditions that make free research possible in the first place. In addition to academic freedom itself, these include independent courts and a free press—together, they serve as a counterweight to the government of the day. What particularly struck me at the symposium was how insidiously these freedoms can be lost. We should not wait to react until scientific institutions are already under political pressure.
In his lecture, Michael Zürn highlighted a second point: Democracy requires not only independent institutions, but also a common foundation of verifiable facts. We may hold very different political views. But when the question of whether something is true hardly plays a role in public debate anymore, reaching mutual understanding becomes increasingly difficult. This is another reason why independent science is so important for our democracy.
One topic at the symposium was the threat to academic freedom in the U.S. under Trump and in Hungary under Viktor Orbán, as well as potential restrictions under an AfD-led government in Saxony-Anhalt. How can academia in Germany be made more resilient? What can be learned from the experiences in the U.S. and Hungary? How was this discussed?
Political influence on academia can take many different forms. In the U.S., we see how quickly decisions regarding funding and funding conditions directly affect the work of universities and research institutions. Andrea Pető has described how, in Hungary, institutions formally remain in place but gradually lose their independence—for example, through political control of resources, changes in leadership, or increasing pressure on researchers. For Germany, this means we must protect our institutions before their independence comes under pressure.
Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf has made very concrete proposals on this topic. A key point is the balance between base funding and program-based funding: the more universities and institutes depend on time-limited programs, the easier it is to control them through funding. Stronger base funding makes them more resilient—I see this just as clearly from my experience leading an institute. She has also proposed distributing research funds in a manner similar to that of public broadcasting.
It is precisely this separation between the government and the allocation of funds that has been lost in Hungary. With regard to Saxony-Anhalt, I found another point important: According to Article 91b of the Basic Law, joint federal and state funding of universities requires the consent of all states. A single state government seeking to exert political control over academia would thus have influence far beyond its own state. This could only be changed through an amendment to the Basic Law. Targeted attacks on researchers have so far been rare in Germany—but, as Ms. Brosius-Gersdorf has emphasized, they are already laid out in some party platforms.
For me, however, resilience also includes a culture of solidarity. When researchers are publicly discredited or threatened, their institutions must not leave them to fend for themselves. They need backing, professional communication, and legal support, and the structures to provide this must be put in place now, not only when a crisis arises. We have good conditions in Germany—but we should not confuse them with a guarantee.
As a virologist, you represent a field that—at least since the COVID-19 pandemic—has come under heavy fire from certain political quarters. What strategies do you use to protect yourself personally against this? Where do you see an urgent need for action on the part of policymakers and the scientific community?
During the pandemic, I’ve seen how quickly a scientific discussion can turn into a personal confrontation. Criticism of data, methods, and conclusions is part of science; it’s necessary and welcome. Personal defamation, threats, and targeted disinformation have nothing to do with that. I now make very conscious decisions about when to respond publicly and when not to give additional attention to a wave of outrage. You don’t have to respond to every claim, but scientifically untenable assertions shouldn’t be left unchallenged as a matter of principle.
Stefan Rahmstorf has described, in the context of climate research, how established findings are deliberately called into question and doubts are amplified. I’ve observed similar mechanisms during the pandemic: at some point, the focus shifts from the scientific data itself to undermining trust in science as a whole. I believe we must not grow accustomed to the idea that scientists have to accept personal hostility as a natural part of their public work. I also see scientific institutions as bearing responsibility in this regard. Anyone who publicly communicates scientific findings needs legal, communicative, and personal support when the need arises. At the same time, we need more effective ways to combat threats and targeted defamation in the digital sphere. This also requires action on the part of platform operators, lawmakers, and law enforcement agencies.
With my own presentation, I wanted to draw attention to something else: How do we talk about the pandemic in retrospect? Over time, facts become memories, and memories often become highly simplified narratives. If we ignore the uncertainty of that time and judge complex decisions solely from today’s perspective, we risk further eroding trust in science and institutions. Yet we will urgently need this trust during the next crisis.
Questions: Dirk Frank