A new nationwide new study finds that 82 percent of parents of school-aged children with disabilities oppose separate schooling. Even among parents whose children currently attend special schools, 69 percent say they would prefer to send their child to attend a mainstream school if the conditions there were better.
The study, “Inclusive Education: Between Aspiration and Reality,” was published by Deutsches Institut für Menschenrechte [German Institute for Human Rights]. For the first time, around 7,500 parents of children with disabilities across Germany were surveyed about their experiences. The quantitative survey, which forms the basis of the analysis, was conducted by Vera Moser, who holds the Kathrin and Stefan Quandt Endowed Professorship in Inclusion Research at Goethe University Frankfurt, together with her research associate Alicia Hanf.
The study also highlights striking regional differences across Germany: In the state of Bremen, only 9 percent of children with disabilities attend special schools, compared with 66 percent in Bavaria. According to the report, special schools increasingly serve as a fallback for children whose needs cannot be adequately met in mainstream schools because of structural shortcomings in the education system.
Another key finding is that 41 percent of parents receive a recommendation to enroll their child in a special school, while only 24 percent are advised to choose a mainstream school. The report argues that too little attention is paid to the long-term consequences of these decisions, which frequently mark the beginning of a lifetime of exclusion. Around 73 percent of students leave special schools without a formal school-leaving qualification, limiting their educational and career prospects. Many move into separate vocational training programs that offer restricted access to the open labor market, and a significant number ultimately find employment only in sheltered workshops for people with disabilities.
The German Institute for Human Rights also points to evidence showing that students with special educational needs achieve better learning outcomes in mainstream schools. When parents are informed about inclusive education options during the advisory process, they are significantly more likely to choose a mainstream school. The study further shows that children with disabilities are four times more likely to be transferred out of mainstream schools than to be admitted into them, underscoring the continuing barriers to inclusive education.