
Dr Moritz Verdenhalven has researched the history of the Frankfurt Psychiatric Clinic’s collection.
For decades, the collection of the Psychiatric Clinic at Frankfurt University Hospital contained medical specimens with human tissue. Little attention was paid to these “human remains,” which remained hidden and largely forgotten – or perhaps deliberately repressed. Over the course of a three-year research project, Dr. Moritz Verdenhalven investigated the origins of the collection. Supported by Goethe University’s management and Frankfurt University Hospital, he set out to reconstruct the history behind the specimens and the people from whom they came. In a recent lecture, Verdenhalven offered insights into both his research process and his findings.
The room at the center of Verdenhalven’s work lies one floor below the lecture hall where around 50 people gathered for the event. Shelves line the space, filled with jars and boxes containing specimens dating from the 1920s to the 1970s. For many years, both the room and its contents remained out of public view. Earlier attempts to examine the history of the collection had never succeeded, noted Prof. Andreas Reif, Director of the Clinic for Psychiatry, Psychosomatics and Psychotherapy, in his opening remarks. That changed when psychiatrist Moritz Verdenhalven – driven by a strong interest in history – joined the university hospital and approached the project with what Reif described as “great commitment and care.”
Even the language used to describe the collection presents challenges and a delicate balancing act, Verdenhalven emphasized at the beginning of his lecture. Terms such as “teaching materials,” “specimens,” or “objects” may be technically convenient, but they risk obscuring the fact that these are human remains. Especially in the context of Nazi crimes, he argued, language requires particular sensitivity. The National Socialists themselves employed dehumanizing terminology, including the ancient Greek word “euthanasia” – literally meaning “good death” – to describe the systematic murder of patients by physicians. One of Verdenhalven’s central aims was therefore to restore visibility to the individuals behind the specimens and, wherever possible, recover their names.
The collection comprises around 9,000 specimens from more than 2,000 deceased individuals dating from 1920 to 1970. It includes both dry and wet preparations in varying states of preservation, many consisting of organ sections considered relevant to neurology and neuropathology. In keeping with the project’s focus, Verdenhalven concentrated primarily on the years between 1939 and 1945. Only a smaller portion of the collection originates from this period – specimens from 218 deceased individuals in total. The research began with index cards documenting the location, year and cause of death, alongside incomplete autopsy and admission records.
According to current estimates, approximately 300,000 people became victims of the Nazi regime’s so-called “euthanasia” program. Individuals with mental illness or disabilities were deemed “lives unworthy of living” by the National Socialists. Not all victims were murdered directly. Many died as a result of systematic neglect, starvation and inadequate care – a practice Verdenhalven describes as “systemic killing.”
When the National Socialists came to power in 1933, neurologist Karl Kleist (1879–1960) had already led Frankfurt’s Psychiatric Clinic for more than a decade. Kleist, whose holistic approach strongly shaped the clinic well into the 1950s, also left a lasting imprint on the collection itself, which largely overlaps with his tenure. Yet questions remain about his relationship to National Socialism and the regime’s “euthanasia” program. Historical records show that after visiting a psychiatric institution in 1938, Kleist criticized cost-cutting measures that contributed to patient deaths. In 1943, he raised concerns with municipal health authorities about patients’ living conditions. During the Hadamar trial in 1947, he unequivocally rejected the notion of “lives unworthy of living” – a position that was by no means universally shared within the medical profession even after the war.
At the same time, German university hospitals referred large numbers of patients to sanatoriums and psychiatric institutions – around 1,200 people from Frankfurt alone. Earlier research concluded that killings did not take place directly at the university hospital itself. However, there is no doubt that systematic murders occurred in the institutions to which patients were transferred. Despite this, medical professionals continued referring patients there and, after their deaths, conducted research on their organs. Between 1933 and 1935, the number of organs sent from sanatoriums to the university hospital increased significantly before declining again after 1939, likely due to wartime staff shortages. One particularly disturbing detail, Verdenhalven noted, was that patient records often included instructions requesting that the brain be sent to the university hospital in the event of death. In this way, the killings were framed as serving scientific research.
Of the 218 individuals whose organs were preserved between 1933 and 1945 and remain part of the clinic’s collection today, the majority died at the university hospital itself. Seven are confirmed to have died in sanatoriums, while the place of death for another 54 individuals remains unknown. Among them are two soldiers whose causes of death are unclear – one died at the military hospital in Frankfurt’s Bürgerspital, while the place of death of the other remains unidentified. “For those who died in the sanatoriums, it can be assumed that their deaths were not natural,” Verdenhalven said, drawing on his extensive research into the institutions involved.
The future of the specimens remains unresolved. They are no longer used in medical teaching or research, Verdenhalven explained, but retain considerable scientific, historical and documentary value as evidence of the injustices committed under Nazi medicine. Human remains from the Nazi period whose provenance remains uncertain are therefore still being preserved. The long-term goal is a dignified burial. Yet crucial information is often still missing, including names, places of origin, religious affiliations or surviving relatives.
For Verdenhalven, the decision not to proceed with burial before clarifying provenance also reflects lessons learned from earlier decades. In the early 1990s, a broad consensus emerged in Germany that specimens from the Nazi era should be removed from collections and buried as quickly as possible – both to end their public display and to avoid further controversy. Today, Verdenhalven argued, such an approach would be seen differently because it would eliminate the possibility of provenance research and the restoration of individual identities. At that time, specimens originally belonging to the psychiatric clinic’s collection were also buried after having been transferred to the university’s neuropathological institute, the Edinger Institute, in the postwar years.
Discussions are already underway with the cemetery administration regarding an appropriate form of burial for the victims who have been clearly identified. The seven individuals definitively established as victims of Nazi persecution must not be forgotten, Verdenhalven emphasized. How they should be commemorated – for example through a memorial plaque on Niederrad Campus – has yet to be decided. After three years of research, Verdenhalven’s conclusion remains necessarily open-ended: “The project is complete, but many questions remain unanswered.”
Anke Sauter