Skip to main content

When Transparency Changes Creativity

New transparency requirements for AI-generated content have been in force across the European Union since August 2, 2026. As major AI providers develop technical solutions to make the origins and creation of digital content traceable, a new study involving Goethe University Frankfurt examines a largely overlooked side effect of this push for transparency: what does labelling content as AI-generated actually do to human creativity?

Providers of systems that were already on the market before August 2, 2026, have a transitional period until December 2 to comply with the new requirements. Since Anthropic announced a new watermark for AI-generated text (see box), at the latest, the industry has once again been abuzz with efforts to find new technical solutions. Meanwhile, a study raises a more fundamental question: Could making the use of generative AI visible actually weaken the very human creative contribution that greater transparency is intended to make more apparent?

By Me, Myself and Machine?

Previous research has focused primarily on how mandatory AI disclosures affect audience evaluations. A research team led by Professor Kevin Bauer of Goethe University Frankfurt and Professor Ekaterina Jussupow of TU Darmstadt, shifts the attention to the creators themselves: How does creative collaboration between humans and machines change when people know from the outset that their use of generative AI will be disclosed? The study “The Indirect Disclosure Effect: How Disclosing Generative AI Use Impacts Human Creative Collaboration with AI” thus approaches the issue from a different perspective.

Drawing on Erving Goffman’s concept of impression management, the researchers suggest that when disclosure is expected, creators may worry that audiences will underestimate their own contribution to the final result It is therefore not only the actual label that changes how the finished product is perceived by its audience. The expectation of that label can already influence, on the production side, how much human creativity goes into the process at all. The authors refer to this mechanism as the “indirect disclosure effect”.

For their study, the researchers conducted two related mixed-methods experiments. Participants used a text-to-image generator to create images under different disclosure conditions. Central to the experiments was whether participants expected the people evaluating their work to be told about their use of generative AI. The researchers also examined whether it made a difference if participants expected their work to be judged by laypeople or by experts.

The results reveal a striking effect: when creators expected a lay audience to be told about their use of AI, they withdrew more from the creative process and gave the generative AI greater latitude. Their prompts contained 31.9 percent fewer words, while their self-reported effort fell by 13.9 percent. The researchers identify a key reason for this behavior: participants were concerned that audiences would fail to recognize their own creative contribution to the final result.

The researchers argue that the effect is not simply a consequence of the disclosure itself. What matters is creators’ expectation that audiences may fail to recognize or give due credit to their own creative contribution. Interestingly, the effect largely disappeared when participants expected their work to be judged by an expert audience: with an expert jury, the observed effects were small and no longer statistically significant.

The change in the creative process ultimately affects the end result as well. Images created in anticipation of disclosure were rated as more novel, but also as less visually appealing. Disclosure therefore does not only influence how audiences evaluate AI-assisted work – an effect examined in other studies. It can already change the kind of work that gets created in the first place.

This is precisely the tension highlighted by the study: transparency rules are intended to make human authorship and accountability more traceable. Yet the label “AI-generated” can encompass very different forms of human-AI collaboration – from an almost entirely automated image to a work in which a person played a substantial role in both its conception and execution, but which nevertheless receives the designation “AI-generated” as a result of the legal framework and the way its provisions are interpreted.

The authors therefore warn of a paradox: if the use of generative AI is disclosed through a simple label alone, regulation could inadvertently weaken the very human creative contribution it is intended to make visible and protect – before the audience even sees the label.

 

Leonie Schultens

When Transparency Changes Creativity | Goethe-University