
Germany’s comparatively resilient democracy today may, at least in part, be rooted in the country’s culture of remembrance.
Using artistic methods, American artist, design educator, and attorney Ryan Lilienthal explores multidirectional and multiperspectival approaches to remembering National Socialism. Participation lies at the heart of his work, which also involves collaborations with students in Germany. The project is funded by the German-American Fulbright Commission and the German federal government and receives academic support from the “Education After Auschwitz” teaching and research forum.
A family history marked by flight and displacement shaped Lilienthal’s path. His ancestors came from Elmshausen, a village in Germany’s Lauter Valley, and were persecuted under the Nazi regime. “After the war and their relocation, my parents saw themselves as new Americans, but throughout their lives they also considered themselves refugees. That had a profound impact on me and influenced my first career choice: by studying law, I wanted to create a sense of continuity with their life story,” he explains. For three decades, Lilienthal worked as an immigration attorney in the United States, representing people with deeply moving and often dramatic life stories as they sought legal residency. “I believed strongly in the importance of that work,” he says, “but I always felt my true calling was art – especially painting.” At 50, he decided to change course professionally and began studying design, focusing on the possibilities of three-dimensional representation and virtual reality technologies. Since then, questions of memory and remembrance have become central to his artistic practice.
Learning from Other Memories
How can people actively engage with remembrance beyond monuments and memorial sites? This question lies at the core of Lilienthal’s work. He is particularly interested in the concept of “multidirectional memory,” which explores remembrance not as a reproduction of victimhood narratives, but as a dynamic exchange between different historical experiences. “In my work as an artist, I want to learn from people with different, often traumatic pasts – not to determine whose memories are ‘worse,’” Lilienthal explains. “I’m interested in how people process their histories, what I can learn from them, and what they, perhaps, might take away from me. These encounters contain important mechanisms of reflection and coping.” Lilienthal has spoken with many people in Germany, including residents of Elmshausen, the village from which his family was deported. There he met an elderly couple who still remembered his relatives. “The couple could barely walk, but they insisted on taking me along a difficult path to the fields that had once belonged to my uncle before the deportation,” he recalls. “After we had already said goodbye, the woman called out to me once more: ‘We were simply too weak back then.’” The encounter left a deep impression on him and prompted him to reflect on the common maxim that one must always resist injustice. Would he himself have resisted injustice under such a regime – or simply conformed? Lilienthal also draws connections to contemporary developments in the United States. Referring to recent events in Minneapolis, he notes: “People who stood up for others during a demonstration were shot by ICE officers. When I look at developments in parts of the US today, I would say Germany has developed a more resilient democracy – and perhaps that is partly connected to the culture of remembrance that has taken root here.”
He finds it both fascinating and deeply moving to see how refugees living in Germany today respond to his work and bring their own histories into the conversation. Alongside remembrance itself, participation plays a central role in his thinking: remembrance, he argues, must be experienced actively if it is to have lasting impact. “When you build a conventional monument, it may become a place people visit from time to time,” he says. “But over the years, many monuments fade into the background. People see them without really seeing them anymore. So, the question becomes: how can remembrance itself become unforgettable? And how can participation in remembrance processes become meaningful for people approaching history from very different experiences and perspectives?”
Young People Create Multifaceted Forms of Remembrance
Recently, Lilienthal carried out a remembrance project with six school classes, placing active participation at its center. As part of his exhibition “Prozesse der Entrechtung und Verfolgung und Tonwerk ‘Shaping Responses to National Socialism’” at the State Archives in Darmstadt, where he explored his personal family history, artworks created by students from Darmstadt, Ober-Ramstadt, Elmshausen, Gadernheim, Pfungstadt, and Bensheim were also presented.
The students inscribed porcelain bricks with words associated with belonging and identity. The bricks were then fired in a kiln and illuminated as part of a collective remembrance sculpture composed of all the student works. For the project, the students used authentic molds based on bricks from the former Heppenheim Clay Works, where Lilienthal’s ancestors had been subjected to forced labor. The illuminated porcelain bricks cast a distinctive light onto the original clay bricks within the installation. Some students also worked with personal documents and letters belonging to victims of Nazi persecution. By transferring handwritten signatures and reconstructing fragments of individual biographies, they sought to restore a sense of identity and personal connection.
“Working with these young people was an extraordinary experience,” Lilienthal says. “It showed me that engaging with history – even its darkest chapters – is entirely compatible with curiosity, creativity, and enthusiasm. It is also about overcoming a fear of history.” After the exhibition concluded, the bricks were returned to the students, who now have the option of using them to create exhibitions of their own – “if they want to,” the artist adds.
Academic Integration
Lilienthal expresses deep gratitude for the academic and advisory support provided by the “Education After Auschwitz” teaching and research forum within Goethe University Frankfurt’s Faculty of Educational Sciences. “Susanne Thimm, a research associate on Professor Meseth’s team, comes from a background in museum education and researches architectural and design history, while I come from design and am interested in pedagogy,” he explains. “It was an ideal fit.”
As part of her master’s thesis in educational sciences, Alina Plohmann conducted empirical research on the project and situated it within broader educational reflections on remembrance practices. “This created a productive dialogue between Ryan Lilienthal’s artistic perspective and our field,” says Wolfgang Meseth, who heads the “Education After Auschwitz” teaching and research forum. “It enabled us to examine the interplay between aesthetic, memory-political, and educational dimensions in projects of this kind from the perspective of educational science.”
Plohmann’s research highlights the diverse ways students engaged with the project and approached the history of Nazi crimes. The project’s unusually long-term and process-oriented format, combined with the productive interaction between aesthetic practice and local historical research, demonstrates how alternative approaches to Nazi history can break with the routines of conventional classroom learning. In doing so, such projects create space for students to develop their own perspectives on the relationship between past and present – and to explore those connections creatively and critically.
Dirk Frank