Skip to main content

Prospects for Democracy

Three new fellows join the interdisciplinary research network “Democratic Vistas” at the Forschungskolleg Humanwissenschaften Institute for Advanced Studies.

Are we facing a dual crisis of democracy and transatlantic relations? This question lies at the center of political scientist Dr. Patrick Nitzschner’s current research project, “Reconstructing Transatlantic Democracy in Times of Crisis” at the Forschungskolleg Humanwissenschaften Institute for Advanced Studies. Against the backdrop of what many perceive as a dual crisis, Nitzschner examines how the history of transatlantic societies has been shaped by changing understandings of democracy. “Crisis discourses often signal shifts in terminology,” he explains. While the post-Cold War period was largely defined by debates about the global expansion of democracy, discussions since the 2010s have increasingly focused on the defense of existing democratic systems. “This appears to indicate a paradigm shift.” At the same time, Nitzschner argues that both expansion and defense have always been foundational elements of democratic thought as it evolved after the interwar period.

Patrick Nitzschner, Laure Gillot-Assayag and Courtney Blair Hodrick.

Patrick Nitzschner, Laure Gillot-Assayag and Courtney Blair Hodrick.

FKH

Many observers in Europe hope that political change in the United States could lead to a renewed period of transatlantic cohesion. But is this expectation realistic? Nitzschner remains cautious: “Such a return is unlikely because transatlantic harmony never truly existed. While the second Trump administration may appear to many as a decisive turning point – and there are indeed significant shifts in transatlantic relations – the sense that the alliance is in crisis has accompanied it throughout much of its history.” During the Cold War, he notes, the mobilization of transatlantic societies against a clearly defined external threat helped sustain political cohesion. Today, however, the threat landscape has become far more complex and difficult to translate into a single political narrative that resonates broadly across society. “This points to less harmony and more political conflict. The future viability of transatlantic relations will ultimately be measured by the quality of that conflict.” Is the much-discussed crisis of Western democracies, which also manifests itself in Germany, a sign of a broader global paradigm shift? For Nitzschner, debates about the future of democracy are always also debates about conflict within democracy itself. Democracies remain resilient when they are able to articulate and negotiate internal tensions, even if doing so inevitably produces contradictions. “Current attempts to define democracy more narrowly and fortify it institutionally are less a paradigm shift than an expression of this tension. A genuine paradigm shift might instead involve approaching social transformation with a stronger sense of democratic openness, rather than joining the widespread narrative of democratic decline.”

Dr. Courtney Blair Hodrick works at the intersection of German studies, Jewish studies, philosophy, and political theory. She describes her research project, “The Concept of Hope in the Work of Hannah Arendt,” as an exploration of political hope beyond both religion and historical determinism: “In my dissertation, I argued that Arendt offers a form of hope that is neither metaphysical – that is, religious – nor rooted in the philosophy of history and ideas of inevitable progress. Instead, this hope is grounded in the human capacity to act in the world and to begin something new.” Her current research focuses on two central themes: the role of thinking in politics and the Jewish dimensions of Arendt’s philosophy. Hodrick explores some of the questions raised by Arendt, such as: “Is there a way of thinking that is not tyrannical?” and asks how modern notions of historical progress may themselves contain tyrannical tendencies. “According to Arendt, the idea of progress contains a tyrannical aspect because human action is understood as the result of a process or law – comparable to the laws of nature studied by the natural sciences. In that framework, human beings no longer act freely but merely obey. Arendt identified this logic particularly in the Soviet Union’s understanding of history.” In response to how Arendt’s ideas might provide a way out of the current crises facing Western liberal democracies, Hodrick points to another problem with the concept of historical progress, the belief in which has become a form of metaphysics. “We cannot prove the so-called laws of the human sciences in a laboratory,” she says. “Part of the current crises facing Western liberal democracies may in fact be a crisis of faith – not faith in God, but faith in progress. If we begin to think differently about politics, we may also discover new and more reliable sources of political hope.”

Political scientist Dr. Laure Gillot-Assayag examines how ethical standards are defined and negotiated in the European Parliament and the US Congress. In her view, efforts to strengthen parliamentary integrity reveal deeper disagreements over what constitutes ethical political behavior: “Based on an analysis of ethics committees, codes of conduct, and parliamentary debates, I argue that contemporary political ethics reflect a revival of republicanism, interpreted in different ways – as the rule of law, civic virtue, or non-domination – and that these interpretations shape different regulatory approaches within political parties and institutions.” Her future research will investigate how ethical traditions in the United States and the European Union influence one another and circulate across political parties, highlighting both convergences and persistent tensions. According to Gillot-Assayag, debates over parliamentary ethics are not only about the design of rules but also about their underlying justification, which reflects competing normative currents of republican thought. In the United States, Congress established its first ethics committee in 1967 in response to political scandals. Although the committee is institutionalized and bipartisan, external oversight remains limited and frequently politicized. “Republicans tend to emphasize non-interference and view ethics rules as arbitrary constraints, while Democrats place greater emphasis on civic virtue, integrity and accountability,” Gillot-Assayag explains. In the European Parliament, reforms introduced since the 1990s have focused primarily on transparency, lobbying, and conflicts of interest. Recent corruption scandals and the 2024 agreement on an interinstitutional EU ethics body – a project that has since stalled – illustrate the increasing politicization of ethics regulation within the European Union. While the European People’s Party has opposed additional institutional oversight, socialist factions have argued in favor of stronger institutional safeguards. “These examples demonstrate that long-standing republican traditions shape support for – or resistance to – ethical regulations within parliaments more strongly than short-term party strategies,” Gillot-Assayag concludes.

 

Dirk Frank

Prospects for Democracy | Goethe-University