Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

“Even if only 100 people watch it, it still matters”

Linda Schlegel on her award-winning dissertation on narrative extremism prevention 

UniReport: Storytelling as a way to counter radicalization – that’s the focus of your dissertation, which was awarded the Hessian Doctoral Prize for Democracy Research. How did you come up with your topic?

Linda Schlegel: I love creative writing. Ever since I was taught how to hold a pen, I haven’t stopped writing. I’ve always written stories and read a lot. And I was determined to focus on prevention in my doctoral work. While it is good, important, and fascinating that so many publications dealing with extremism exist, I was most interested in the question: What can we do about it?

 

Having started from there, it then made sense to look at narrative campaigns against extremism.

Exactly. After I began reading up on the topic, I was initially very confused. These campaigns were being described as if they weren’t really stories at all, but rather argument-based political communication, with the corresponding theories in the background. I found that strange. The evaluations of these campaigns also showed relatively small or even no effects. To me, it was clear why – because they aren’t actually narratives at all.

 

Why is storytelling so important in your view?

I strongly believe in the power of storytelling. It is well known that extremists are very skilled and effective at storytelling, which plays a major role in the process of radicalization. Ideally, that should work just as well on the side of democracy.

 

But the state or civil society can’t just invent things out of thin air, can they?

I often hear this argument in the interviews I conduct with experts. My response is this: Extremist actors don’t just spread fabricated lies; many utopian narratives also exist: “We’re building a new state, we’re improving society, we’re doing this, that, and the other to make things better for us, for the children, and so on.” What we have here is fiction dressed as a forward-looking utopian narrative.

 

Might this not work for the democratic mainstream, too?

It is by no means set in stone that we must always limit ourselves to saying: we are defending the status quo. Political communication can absolutely involve visions of a better society. Just think of Martin Luther King’s “I Have a Dream” speech. I, for one, believe we actually need such communication, also because democratic disillusionment emerges when we fail to show a way forward.

 

Political campaign advertising often constructs just these kinds of future scenarios. Is that what you have in mind?

The agency around the corner that develops campaigns for DIY stores like Bauhaus and other companies often tells highly creative stories. Political communication, by contrast, many times feels stale and uninspired. One of my interviewees told me about attending a conference on political communication where he came close to falling asleep. Then suddenly this really cool video was shown: great music, young men running through the desert. He thought: Yes, finally! Until he realized it was an ISIS video.

 

So we should learn from extremists?

Of course we cannot turn political communication into Hollywood blockbusters. But we do need to offer something inspiring – a vision. We are very good at pointing out what is wrong and countering with facts, much less so when it comes to presenting a genuine alternative…

 

How did you approach your dissertation?

First, I looked at the question: what exactly is a narrative? How do narratives persuade people to adopt a particular worldview? There are decades of research on this, hundreds of case studies, mostly in the field of entertainment-education. Then I examined the literature on narrative campaigns against extremism and was shocked to find virtually no reference to this body of narrative research.

 

You mean literature on narrative campaigns that ignores the effects of narratives?

Yes. The focus was always on arguments and target groups. But if you want to create narrative campaigns, narrative persuasion should matter too. My first step was therefore theoretical: how can I apply my insights from entertainment-education and narrative persuasion to the field of extremism prevention? I also conducted several expert interviews.

 

Which experts did you speak with?

I interviewed researchers and practitioners working in extremism prevention in Germany and the UK. I just could not believe that I might be the first person to notice this literature gap. I thought I must have overlooked something. But the interviews confirmed the deep-seated skepticism toward storytelling. And then it became clear to me why these so-called “narrative campaigns” seem more like political communication than actual stories.

 

Who exactly did you interview?

I focused on Germany and the UK – two very different prevention landscapes. In Germany, prevention work has existed since the 1990s, especially in the field of right-wing extremism, and it is heavily NGO-based: the state provides funding, while many small organizations run many small projects. In the UK, it is exactly the opposite. There, the prevention landscape emerged largely in response to the jihadist threat and is highly centralized under the Home Office. I originally set out to identify differences but found myself unable to – there simply weren’t any. Everyone was extremely skeptical about narratives.

 

But your dissertation was intended as a counterpoint to that skepticism.

Yes, which is precisely why I also analyzed a narrative campaign. “Jamal al-Khatib”, an Austrian video campaign aimed at extremism prevention, was already considered an effective best-practice example. This allowed me to complement existing studies of this particular campaign by analyzing the videos from a storytelling perspective – to see which aspects of the narrative worked well and which did not.

 

Wouldn’t it make more sense to measure impact directly?

Impact measurement could easily become a dissertation topic in its own right, but is difficult to carry out. One has to be extremely careful: what you measure “in the lab” is not the same as what happens in reality. Narrative campaigns often do not produce immediately measurable effects; their impact may emerge only later, in retrospect. It is, after all, not every day that we change our worldview. Narrative campaigns do not work that way either – and we should not expect them to.

 

How does a clip like that even reach its target audience?

That is a huge problem. There are excellent campaigns that are seen by only 30 people – half of whom are political educators or researchers. If everyone still watched television at the same time, you could produce these spots like people did in the 1980s. On social media, you have to consider the underlying algorithm to get the content pushed into people’s feeds. The “Jamal al-Khatib” campaign tried to do this through hashtags that were popular within jihadist online spaces. But that does not always work. This is one of the major challenges facing prevention work today.

 

Isn’t that also a technical problem?

Absolutely – and it is also a problem rooted in the characteristics of the platforms themselves. Ten years ago, I might have produced a ten-minute YouTube video. Today, if I want to reach kids on TikTok, I get thirty seconds. But what can you really tell in thirty seconds? The content is supposed to be nuanced; we are not allowed to tell people what they must believe, because that would amount to state propaganda. In Germany, political communication is governed by the principle of the “Überwältigungsverbot”, which explicitly prohibits one-sided forms of persuasion. [editor’s note: The “Überwältigungsverbot” is a civic-education principle intended to safeguard students’ ability to form independent political judgments.]

 

So existing campaigns must outsmart the algorithm while keeping the message short.

Exactly. Some people have in fact already concluded that the digital sphere is impossible to reach in this manner and that we should abandon it altogether. But in offline settings, you only reach the people who happen to be sitting in a workshop or classroom – often because they have to. Which begs the question about the kind of impact such efforts can really have. We know that extremist actors are especially active in digital spaces.

 

Abstaining from the digital sphere is no real solution either.

I personally believe there are two levels to consider. One is the effect on the individual watching the content. But looking at the broader discursive level, you might also conclude that even if only 100 people from among the intended target audience actually watch it, it still matters – because it constitutes at least one alternative to extremist voices in the digital sphere. Extremist actors are a very loud minority and therefore appear disproportionately influential. At the very least, we have inserted a counter-voice into the conversation.

 

Are you more optimistic or more pessimistic about these developments?

Well, I do think we are more aware today of the need to open ourselves to new formats. The problem, as always, is funding: who is willing to pay for this? And how much creative freedom are people actually given? If a ministry issues a call for proposals that severely limits what applicants are allowed to do, then creativity is constrained from the outset. With funding more likely to be cut today, the trend in extremism prevention is moving in the opposite direction.

 

But the prize you received from the science minister does send a signal.

Yes. A dedicated program on democracy research was set up specifically for this purpose in Hesse. Goethe University Frankfurt is also involved in DemoReg, a joint project with Marburg University. So at least in our federal state, something is happening and creating visibility for democracy research as a whole.

 

Questions: Anke Sauter

Picture of Linda Schlegel

Linda Schlegel

Privat

Linda Schlegel on her award-winning dissertation