Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

Great Art – But No High Culture?

An Interview with Peter Breunig and Gabriele Franke on the Major Research Project Exploring the Nok Culture in Nigeria

Expressive faces, elaborate hairstyles and sophisticated iron-smelting techniques – archaeologists and archaeobotanists from Frankfurt have spent many years researching the Nok culture in Nigeria, renowned for its remarkable terracotta sculptures. In an engaging, richly illustrated book, Professor Peter Breunig, Dr. Gabriele Franke and Tanja Männel bring together the findings of their research and trace the history of the project itself. Their work has also been featured in an ARTE documentary. One thing quickly becomes clear in conversation with Peter Breunig and Gabriele Franke: The Secret of the Nok Culture – the title of their book – has by no means been fully revealed.

Photo gallery from the excavation

UniReport: The Nok terracottas have attracted worldwide attention since their discovery in the late 1920s. How did you become involved in this field of research?

Peter Breunig: Through the DFG (German Research Foundation) Collaborative Research Center on West Africa (SFB 268: History of Culture and Language in the Natural Environment of the West African Savannah), we knew that significant changes had taken place rather suddenly in the Chad Basin during the first millennium BC. We wanted to find out whether this was an isolated development or whether similar processes were occurring elsewhere in West Africa. It therefore made sense to focus on the artistic clay figures found south of the Chad Basin. Our long-term project officially began in 2008, although we had been preparing for it since 2004.

 

The first figures were discovered by chance during tin mining, which soon led to looting and forgery. Had there really been so little systematic research since then?

Gabriela Franke: In fact, the British archaeologist Bernard Fagg carried out systematic research. But in more recent decades, very little had happened, and many sites had already been destroyed by looters. That was the situation we encountered.

 

What exactly were you hoping to find?

Breunig: We wanted to understand how complex social and political structures emerge. The terracottas are artistically sophisticated and stylistically remarkably consistent, and there was evidence of early ironworking. At first, we assumed these achievements must have been supported by a highly complex society.

 

When did you realize that this assumption wasn’t borne out?

Breunig: Fairly early on. We found no evidence of large settlements, monumental architecture or a flourishing economy capable of supporting large communities. Nor did we find the centralized workshops we had expected, given the standardized production techniques of the terracottas. The evidence simply didn’t support our original hypothesis.

Franke: It would certainly have fitted the picture if we had found early indications of the kinds of complex societies that emerged later. But if the archaeological evidence points elsewhere, then that’s what we have to accept.

 

So how was Nok society organized instead?

Breunig: Everything we know suggests an agricultural society made up of small villages or hamlets organized around extended families. People cultivated millet and cowpeas.

Franke: We found nothing to suggest large houses or distinctive architecture. Occasionally we uncovered fragments of daub – pieces of clay bearing impressions of former wattle structures – but that was about it. In this case, the absence of evidence is itself revealing.

 

What about ironworking?

Breunig: There were probably specialists who focused on extracting and processing iron. We’ve discovered numerous smelting furnaces that were technically quite sophisticated, fitted with nozzles that channeled air into the furnace to generate very high temperatures. These furnaces were used only once before being destroyed, suggesting mobile specialists rather than a centrally organized production system. Iron objects themselves are extremely rare. Everything we’ve recovered fits into one hand: a small axe, a ring and a few fragments that can’t be identified.

Franke: Nok iron is among the earliest known in Africa. The chronology, however, remains difficult to establish because the radiocarbon dates fall somewhere between 800 and 400 BC, which is a fairly broad range. Although a date around 800 BC is theoretically possible, it cannot yet be confirmed with certainty.

 

Nok pioneer Bernard Fagg was cautious about stating just how old he believed the terracottas were.

Franke: Eurocentric thinking made things easy for itself: everything sophisticated was assumed to originate in Europe, while Africans, with what were then labelled “primitive” cultures, were thought incapable of producing such achievements. Had Bernard Fagg argued that the terracottas dated back to 800 BC, it would also have meant accepting ironworking of the same age. Even without making that claim outright, he encountered considerable resistance.

Breunig: Even Grahame Clark’s World Prehistory, published in 1964, argued that Africa had shown promise early on but had since “fallen behind in the race for progress” after the last Ice Age. That way of thinking was deeply ingrained. Whether it was Neolithic agriculture or ironworking, the assumption was always that these innovations must have reached Africa from elsewhere.

 

That’s quite a striking assessment. Let’s return to your own research. At first, most of what you found were pits left behind by looters, and your first informant was a looter himself. How challenging was that situation?

Breunig: Initially, we did work with looters. They knew where the archaeological sites were, and we paid them for that information. Our first collection consisted of objects recovered during looting that couldn’t be sold on the market. Between the looters’ pits, however, untouched areas remained where we were able to carry out scientifically controlled test excavations with increasing success.

Franke: Later, we identified sites ourselves, many of the local workers became permanent members of our team, and we established a well-equipped research station. Between 2011 and 2014, we excavated an area of 2,617 square meters at Pangwari and, for the first time, uncovered a terracotta deposit in a secure archaeological context. That allowed us to begin detailed analysis. We had the opportunity to do so because fieldwork had to be scaled back during certain periods.

Breunig: During that time, we developed a hypothesis to explain the mysterious and widespread deposits of terracottas.

 

What was that hypothesis?

Franke: That the buried terracotta deposits were linked to nearby graves. In 2016, we returned to Nigeria to test this idea through large-scale excavations at previously identified sites. The excavations were successful, but we were unable to continue the work on the same scale.
In 2017, an attack involving a kidnapping claimed two lives. Have you returned since then?

Franke: Yes, several times. But we’ve never gone back to the excavation area itself. The region has become dangerous even for local people.

 

The political situation no longer allows further excavations. How do you deal with that?

Breunig: Naturally, we would have liked to continue. But eventually there comes a point where you have to stop. By carrying out a comprehensive analysis of the material we already collected, we’ve created a solid foundation that will support future research for many years.

 

How would you sum up your findings?

Breunig: That highly accomplished art does not necessarily require a complex society. The Nok culture was an agricultural society that nevertheless developed an extraordinary artistic tradition.

Franke: Another important finding is that the systematic – and apparently deliberate – breaking of terracotta figures points to ritual practices whose meaning we still don’t understand.

 

Do you believe the figures were deliberately broken?

Breunig: There’s a great deal of evidence to suggest that they were. Complete figures are extremely rare. In graves, we found deposits containing numerous fragments, but the pieces didn’t fit together. Parts of the same figure appear to have ended up in different contexts.

Franke: We suspect that the figures were intentionally broken before burial. Perhaps different rules applied in funerary contexts, where intact objects were not permitted. We can’t prove it, but the pattern is striking.

 

Why did the Nok culture disappear?

Franke: We simply don’t know. Climate change affecting both the environment and the economy is one possible explanation. Harvests may have declined, and perhaps the Nok people were reluctant to experiment with crops that were better suited to changing conditions.

Breunig: Environmental degradation caused by deforestation for iron production is another possibility. What we do know is that the Nok culture came to an end during the last centuries BC. It was only about a thousand years later that new, clearly identifiable archaeological cultures, such as Ile-Ife (pronounced Ife Ife), emerged. How they relate to the Nok culture remains one of the most intriguing unanswered questions.

 

Is Nok research continuing in Frankfurt?

Breunig: Not actively at the moment. But we’re always happy to share our knowledge and data if new research projects emerge. Alongside questions about the successors of the Nok culture, there are still many others to explore – for example, how the culture itself originated, whether it developed in isolation, or whether it was connected to similar but still unexplored cultural complexes in neighboring regions.

Franke: In academia, not every question can ever be answered completely. The “mystery of the Nok culture” hasn’t been solved – but today we have a much clearer understanding of what that mystery actually is.

Questions: Anke Sauter

Large Nok terracotta head

Large Nok terracotta head from the Ifana excavation site, photographed during its recovery in 2016.

Breunig/Franke

Great Art – But No High Culture?