Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

Everyday Science Diplomacy: How Research Builds Bridges

Eight people are standing in front of the IG Farben building on the Westend Campus, laughing and hugging each other.

Leonie Schultens

For Birkalan-Gedik, science diplomacy often happens quietly and unnoticed, like at her recent workshop on "Folklore Knowledge and Knowledge Transfer in Transnational Perspectives, the 1950s-1980s", held in mid-September.

Science diplomacy is not just official policy; it often arises from everyday contacts between researchers. Speaking to UniReport, Prof. Dr. Hande Birkalan‑Gedik, laureate of the new Goethe Science Diplomacy Award, explains how individual actors forge connections – often quietly, but with lasting impact.

The newly established Goethe Science Diplomacy Award recognizes academic engagement that goes beyond conventional research excellence and uses international scientific cooperation to foster academic freedom, international understanding and dialogue across political, cultural and societal boundaries. Its overarching motto is “Research Connects Across Borders.” At this year’s annual reception, the Foundation for the Promotion of International Scientific Relations at Goethe University Frankfurt announced that not one but two researchers had been awarded the inaugural honor (read the press release here). UniReport sat down with Prof. Dr. Hande Birkalan-Gedik to find out more about her work and her very own definition of science diplomacy. An interview with fellow award recipient Dr. Ulrich Kuch will follow.

Dr. Ulrich Kuch and Prof. Dr. Hande Birkalan-Gedik are standing side by side, smiling. Between them stands a yellow statue of Goethe.

The first Goethe Science Diplomacy Award went to Dr. Ulrich Kuch (left) and Prof. Dr. Hande Birkalan-Gedik.

Jürgen Lecher

Professor Birkalan-Gedik, you were honored for your science diplomacy – a term many people have heard but few can define. What is your personal definition and what does it mean in your day-to-day work?

Science diplomacy can be defined as the process of using scientific collaboration to strengthen relations between countries, address common global problems and serve foreign policy goals. According to this textbook definition, it works towards building bridges between scientists and diplomats. I don’t think this view is wrong, but it is not how I approach my own work.

Instead of looking at the macro level or searching for differences and differentiations, what matters most for me in science diplomacy are the roles border-crossing actors play – individual scholars, students, and research partners, who move across national and disciplinary lines, often both quietly and unnoticed, and in many cases with no diplomatic mandate at all. This type of knowledge is not produced at the level of states and foreign ministries but in grey zones, in the in-between spaces where a Turkish folklorist corresponds with a German ethnologist, where a workshop invitation turns into a decade-long friendship, where an archive visit in one country becomes the seed of a co-authored chapter written in another.

When I say I do not think “big,” I do not mean I lack a larger vision. In a Sufi sense, to me the way you bring that vision to life is more important: the actions of each and every one of us end up as a single drop in a vast ocean. Change always begins at the individual level and within the realm of what is individually possible. I do not begin with “foreign policy objectives.” All my written and face-to-face communication begins with the person across the table, the colleague I mentor, the invitation I write that reflects a personal interaction and something the other person has said or done. If science diplomacy means anything to me in day-to-day terms, it lies in paying attention to such border-crossing actors, who carry knowledge between contexts, and to trust that enough drops, over enough time, eventually become an ocean.

 

When did you first realize that your research had become more than research and had entered the domain of diplomacy? 

Research is always entangled with politics: at home, in the world, with men and women – and with children. As a child, I always asked the “most unexpected” questions that no one in my surroundings asked. I guess I was thinking out of the box even then. When I started university, I knew that research was not something that takes place for a limited time, confined to a project period or a grant cycle. It becomes a way of seeing, a habit of noticing what others may walk past without ever questioning its existence. So, the honest answer is that, for me, there was no single moment of realization. My research had already exceeded its own boundaries long before I had a name for what I was doing and long before I called it “research.”

 

Have you ever experienced a moment when scientific collaboration opened doors that politics could not?

I find this question a bit off the mark. I am no politician, and I cannot claim to know the contexts in which politicians operate. Science diplomacy is also a separate professional category, and not one I would claim for myself in the larger sense of the term. But both anthropology and feminism start from the same premise that everyday life is itself political terrain. The feminist motto “the personal is political” is proof that politics not only happens in ministries and treaties, but the moment it is decided who gets to speak, whose knowledge counts, and whose everyday practices are dismissed as merely “folk” or “local”.

The question also carries a hidden assumption worth naming. Take, for example, Max Weber’s classic distinction between “Wissenschaft als Beruf” [science as a profession] and “Politik als Beruf” [politics as a profession], which sees science as a value-free pursuit of facts versus politics as the realm of value-laden decision and action. But that distinction collapses under its own weight the moment you ask what scientific knowledge is actually used for. This critique has a long afterlife beyond Weber himself, including the members of the Frankfurt School: Adorno and Horkheimer’s account of instrumental reason can be understood in parallel with Foucault’s insistence that knowledge and power are never separable. More recent work in science and technology studies treats scientific knowledge and political order as mutually constitutive rather than distinct.

Nuclear physics is a case in point: the same body of knowledge that made radiotherapy possible also made Hiroshima possible. The knowledge itself may look neutral. Its application never is. What matters is not whether something is “scientific” or “political,” but who holds the power to decide its use, which is, again, a political question, not a scientific one. This is close to what Donna Haraway called “situated knowledge”: there is no view from nowhere. All knowledge is produced from somewhere, by someone, within certain structures of power, even if it works hard to make that positioning invisible.

So, if collaboration ever opened a door that formal politics could not, it was not because I or potentially also any other researcher stepped into a diplomat’s shoes or because science operates outside politics. It was because attending carefully to the everyday texture of people’s lives and knowledge is itself already a political act. My own work on the history of folklore knowledge in Turkey lives exactly in this tension: deciding what counted as “scientific” knowledge and what got relegated to “mere” folklore was never a neutral, disinterested process. It was a state project, entangled with nation-building, institutional hierarchies, and who was allowed to speak as an expert. Science does not stand outside politics looking in. It has always been political. The question is simply whether we are willing to see it.

 

Trust is central to international cooperation. How do you build trust with partners from very different cultural or political contexts? 

Trust is an important concept for international cooperation. Coming from anthropology and folklore studies, I always think of it as fieldwork. Like fieldwork, it is never stable and should not be taken for granted. It develops with rapport. It finds its pace and application slowly, through repeated encounters, through the small gestures that show you are paying attention to the other person’s world rather than importing your own assumptions into it. You do not arrive with trust already in hand. You earn it, and you can just as easily lose it if you stop listening.

Working across quite diverse cultural or political contexts, I try to adopt my instincts from the field: patience, a willingness to be corrected, and an awareness of my own categories, be they academic, national or disciplinary. I know that they are not universal. Trust with a partner from a different political context often means acknowledging the constraints they work under, without assuming that those constraints define them. It means recognizing that silence, caution, or indirectness may not be reluctance but a rational response to a context I do not fully share.

And as in fieldwork, trust is cumulative but fragile. Ethnographers and their collaborators build it over time, by following their words with actions, and by being transparent about personal limits and positions. Trust is never established in a single meeting; it requires tending, the way one would nurture a long-term relationship with an interlocutor in the field long after the “project” itself has formally ended. Many people mistakenly think fieldwork is limited to a set period of time, when in fact it can last for decades, not only due to long-term research but also because networks and friendships are formed. It is always about maintaining international cooperation and engagement.

 

Has international collaboration become harder over the past decade?

International collaboration has indeed become harder over the past ten years, though the picture differs depending on the level you look at. State-level geopolitical cooperation – in the form of treaties, diplomatic frameworks, or formal bilateral agreements – has frayed visibly as a result of rising nationalism, security disputes, and increasing geopolitical frictions. At the researcher level, by contrast, cooperation has proven more resilient: co-authorships, joint grants, and informal scholarly networks have often persisted even as the formal state architecture around them weakened. I think the key is to remain open to dialogue.

The pandemic played a paradoxical role here. It threw up real barriers – including border closures, travel restrictions, and conference cancelations – but it also pushed researchers to get creative, to build connections and sustain projects entirely online. The digital expertise we have acquired since 2020 has not disappeared now that travel has resumed.

At the same time, stricter border regimes continue to constrain physical mobility: Visas, security screening, and travel restrictions remain real obstacles, particularly for scholars coming from certain regions. But ideas travel differently than people do – they cross boundaries more easily. My own collaboration on Fabrics of Anthropological Knowledge is a case in point: it grew out of online meetings, even though I had also met my colleagues in person more than once before the book was published. The combination mattered, the online exchanges kept the work moving, but the in-person meetings gave it a foundation the Zoom calls alone might not have.

 

Academic freedom is increasingly under pressure in many parts of the world. What responsibilities do universities have when researchers cannot work freely?

I cannot speak for the entire world because the relationship between the states and universities varies considerably depending on where you live, and autonomy can mean different things in different cases. In the larger European context, universities have a responsibility to actively defend the conditions researchers need, such as providing institutional autonomy, securing appointments, and offering legal or logistical support to scholars facing threats, censorship, or exile. They should not stay neutral in the face of such pressure. Where free inquiry is impossible in a researcher’s home context, universities also bear responsibility for building alternative spaces: visiting fellowships, scholar-at-risk programs, and cross-border collaborations that allow the work and the person behind it to continue safely.

 

Is there one collaboration you are particularly proud of – not because of the scientific results, but because of the relationships it created or the societal impact it had?

My recently co-edited book Fabrics of Anthropological Knowledge comes to my mind again. I invited scholars from various parts of the world to contribute their unique case studies on the formation and dissemination of anthropological knowledge. My contributors came from or specialize in Portugal, Mexico, Brazil, Serbia, and Poland, among others. The book received co-funding from Johann Christian Senckenberg University Library and Georg und Franziska Speyer’sche Hochschulstiftung. I am enormously proud – both of the funding I received for this publication and of the geographical scope of the book, which covers “marginalized” anthropological traditions in and beyond Europe in terms of either authorship or thematic emphasis.

 

If you could change one thing about international science today, what would it be?

Answering that question requires a definition of the terms  “international” and “science.” The attribute “international” is often used as a synonym for “Western” – as if collaboration only becomes visible, or only counts, once it crosses into a handful of metropolitan centers, while exchanges among scholars in Turkey, the Balkans, or the Middle East remain invisible and are categorized as “merely regional.” 

As for the term “science”, it is often associated with the so-called “hard sciences”: mathematics, physics, biology, etc. But how do we understand its meaning? Is it still the same “science” when we refer to the “social sciences”? What kind of models and metaphors do we use to conceptualize “science”? 

While I do think metaphors from “science” often find their way aptly into the “social sciences,” To me the term “science” is rather broad. It is not a single method but a plural set of practices. I also observe a hierarchical positioning of “science” over “social sciences”. A physics experiment and ethnographic fieldwork may not operate by the same logic of “evidence,” yet both are systematic, self-correcting, peer-reviewed ways of producing knowledge. In other words, we need to avoid a narrow definition of “science” as “laboratory and white coat.” The social sciences and humanities also produce systematic knowledge, just through different tools.

In anthropology, we criticize certain aspects of positivism, and introduce more humanistic, interpretive approaches to help us understand humans. I personally also draw on and align with feminist research and its criticism of categories in positivist thought.

Looking at the big picture, I cannot help but see a very uneven distribution of resources and infrastructure. Only a handful of researchers work outside the confines of wealthy institutions in wealthy countries, where you enjoy easier access to funding, publishing venues, and collaborative networks. Too much of “international” science still runs through a narrow set of gatekeepers who decide and shape which and whose questions get to be asked. What we need to be asking instead is whose knowledge counts as knowledge. 

One of my favorite scholars, Raewyn Connell, argues that this material inequality goes hand in hand with an epistemic one: it is not enough to redistribute resources fairly; the structures of knowledge production themselves need to change. Supposedly “universal theory” must acknowledge the particular geopolitical locations from which it is produced. Connel treats Global South scholars as genuine theoretical interlocutors rather than data providers and redistributors of centrally produced knowledge – an observation that both resonates and reverberates with my own positioning.

 

Leonie Schultens