The COMET (Consumer Empowerment and Participation in the Smart Living Domain) research project concluded at the end of July 2026. Economist Valerie Carl, a postdoctoral researcher in Prof. Oliver Hinz’s research group, led the project. In this interview with UniReport, she reflects on its main findings and lessons. COMET focused on strengthening users’ control over their data while also giving small and midsize businesses and startups transparent, fair access to valuable user data.
UniReport: Dr. Carl, do you ever find yourself surprised by how readily people share their data with commercial providers?
Valerie Carl: Yes, it’s an interesting phenomenon. When you ask people whether they would share their location data, almost everyone immediately says, “Absolutely not!” But nearly everyone uses Google Maps these days and shares their location data without a second thought in exchange for a free app. In COMET, we asked people whether they would share their electricity data. Most responded, “Electricity data? What would anyone do with that?” People are not yet aware of how sensitive, but also how valuable, this kind of data can be. There’s still a lot of room to raise awareness.
COMET aimed to give users more control over their personal data. You developed two components, COMET Connect and the COMET Personal Data Market. You also took businesses’ needs into account.
That’s right. COMET is essentially a data pipeline between businesses that need data and users. Imagine you run a small or mid-size company and want to train an AI service in a field where you haven’t worked before. If you want to offer a new service, you may first need information about the behavior of potential customers. That’s what the COMET Personal Data Market is for. It provides a way for businesses to request and receive data while also ensuring the data is of high quality. COMET Connect essentially links those businesses with consumers through apps that are already in use. In all, we connected more than 150,000 consumers in Germany to COMET.
So, you connected and integrated apps that were already tried and trusted?
We worked with three different apps. One was EHW+, which lets people track their household consumption, including water, oil, pellets, gas and electricity. Anyone can use it, including renters, by entering their meter readings. We also connected Powerfox, an app that automatically reads electricity consumption. It requires hardware installed at home, so it may be better suited to people who own their house or apartment. The third app, easierLife, is for assisted living. Sensors, such as those on doors and windows, and motion detectors help monitor whether people are doing well at home. For example, if you have older relatives living alone, you can use the app to check on their well-being. We connected all three apps and also developed an app of our own, which we distributed through the project at Goethe University.
Digital services often leave customers feeling they have no choice but to accept a provider’s terms. How can that relationship be made fairer, so people don’t feel they have to take it or leave it?
We all know the routine: If you want to use or set up something online, you have to click to accept the privacy policy and terms and conditions. Few people probably read them, and in the end, they often have no real choice. COMET was designed to avoid exactly that. We built the app so that whenever a business asks a customer for data, the customer can decide on a case-by-case basis. As a customer, I can ask myself: Does it seem reasonable to share my data for this purpose? Is there a benefit in it for me? Maybe I’m comfortable with sharing my data in this particular case. A few weeks later, when the same business asks again, I might decide differently. We also offered consumers an AI-based statistics service. For energy use, it provided energy forecasts; in assisted living, it helped identify changes in the routines of the people being monitored. This gave users a benefit without requiring them to donate their data, in the hope that they would view the project more favorably. More than 90% voluntarily made their data available to Goethe University for further AI training.
So, businesses sometimes need data to develop products or services. There is a market for data, but access to it is not distributed fairly.
Exactly. One of our goals was to break down what are known as data silos. Businesses with access to a lot of data have a distinct advantage in the market and can offer many services. But that can be difficult for small and mid-size businesses and startups in Germany, which initially have access only to their own customers’ data. When companies grow or diversify, perhaps by developing a new AI service, they may not have the data they need. And when they ask other businesses to use their data, the answer is usually no. Legal concerns are often part of the reason. COMET seeks to act as an intermediary, creating a pipeline between businesses that consumers may not yet have a relationship with and data those consumers share through other apps. Companies registered in the SmartLivingNEXT ecosystem could ask customers of EHW+, easierLife and Powerfox for permission to use their data to develop any given new service.
Can the work you did through COMET be continued?
There are several ways to carry the project’s findings and tools forward. The services we developed will remain available through EHW+, easierLife and Powerfox, where they can benefit the 150,000 users. The SmartLivingNEXT ecosystem is now moving toward full operation. We’re in a transition phase, testing whether the ecosystem can sustain itself. Our team is also considering continuing the work as a startup.
COMET also depended on expertise in computer science.
My work is in information systems, and my original background is in industrial engineering, with a focus on mechanical engineering. Information systems research in Frankfurt is a broad field, spanning everything from traditional business studies to technical work in artificial intelligence. For COMET, we also collaborated with the German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence. Interdisciplinary work was central to the project. Our work also required us to build physical and digital infrastructure. At the same time, users needed to understand what they were being asked to consent to in each individual case, and what benefit they might receive.
Interview: Dirk Frank

