Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

In Conversation with… “Everything Falls Into Place”

Three Generations of Law, one University: Claudia and Marietta Schulz and Armin Deppert on Vocation, Educational Tradition, and the Deutschlandstipendium

When three generations of a family attend the same university and choose the same degree program—is that tradition, influence, or simply passion? For the Deppert-Schulz family, it’s probably a little bit of everything. Grandfather Dr. Armin Deppert was a presiding judge at the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court; his wife, Dr. Katharina Deppert, made history as a presiding judge at the Federal Court of Justice. Their daughter, Claudia Schulz, is a judge at the local court. Granddaughter Marietta Schulz is studying law where it all began for this family of lawyers: at Goethe University Frankfurt. A conversation about law as a calling, a Deutschlandstipendium, and the question of whether “justice” is really the right word for lawyers.

Heike Jüngst

Mr. Deppert, at the award ceremony for Goethe University’s Deutschlandstipendium last November, you, your daughter, and your granddaughter Marietta all found yourselves in the same room. What was that moment like?

Dr. Armin Deppert: It was very gratifying. I had been invited as a donor for the scholarship, and when I received the invitation to the award ceremony, I had no idea that my granddaughter Marietta had applied for the Deutschlandstipendium. And she, for her part, didn’t know that I had made the donation. This coincidence told a story that one could hardly have imagined better: three generations connected by Goethe University, all gathered in one room at the university at the same time.

Three generations, the same degree: Is studying law a tradition in your family, or something like a common language?

Dr. Armin Deppert: Perhaps both. We talk to each other about cases, rulings, and legal issues. My wife and I have always made a point of doing that. When you live in the same intellectual world every day, it shapes your own way of seeing things. You learn early on to think in a structured way and in accordance with the law. That’s not a bad foundation for life in general.

Claudia Schulz: Tradition, yes, but without any obligation. You grow up with it when your parents are lawyers. My parents would sometimes talk about their cases, and we’d discuss them quite naturally. That shapes you. And the image you develop—of a profession that has meaning and purpose—stays with you.

Mr. Deppert, you met your wife while studying at Goethe University. You both later earned your doctorates under the same professor. So wasn’t the university for you not only a place of learning, but also a place where you lived your life?

Dr. Armin Deppert: Yes, definitely. Tina and I both earned our doctorates under Professor Schiedermair, an outstanding legal scholar and teacher to whom we owe a great deal. The university was smaller back then; the students mostly knew one another. We were still in the old buildings on the Bockenheim campus—different times, different spaces, but a very good, friendly atmosphere. Of course, I had no idea back then that I would meet the woman there with whom I would spend the rest of my life. Looking back, it was a great gift.

Your wife, Dr. Katharina Deppert, became a judge at the Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe in 1990 and later served as presiding judge at the Federal Court of Justice—one of the first women ever to hold that position in the court’s history. What did it mean to you to witness that?

Dr. Armin Deppert: Strictly speaking, she was the second woman to hold that position in the history of the Reich Court and the Federal Court of Justice. The first was in the 1960s, but that was already a long time ago. It was significant, even though at home we simply saw it for what it was: Tina did her job, and she did it with great joy and passion. I myself was Chief Judge at the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court and retired in 2005—a very fulfilling time. For Tina, Karlsruhe was once again a world of its own: lively, challenging, and enriching. When she died in 2024, it was a profound loss for me, for our family, and for many who knew and cherished her. But what she left behind continues to inspire us.

Ms. Schulz, your mother was one of Germany’s most renowned lawyers, and your father was a presiding judge at the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court. As a child, did that serve as a source of inspiration for you, or did it also create pressure to live up to expectations?

Claudia Schulz: Definitely a source of inspiration, a role model, and always a source of encouragement. Pressure to live up to expectations? No. My parents would have supported any decision I made—except one that would have made me unhappy. The only thing they told me was: “Think carefully about whether this is right for you.” I made my decision by process of elimination. I didn’t want to become a teacher, and I thought that with a law degree, I could make a real difference. Today, I’m a judge at the district court, specializing in civil law, bankruptcy law, and enforcement law. I wouldn’t want to do anything else.

Marietta Schulz: It was similar for me. No pressure, no expectations. I’d done an internship at a law firm before and realized I enjoyed it. And, of course, I used to watch my mother at work. You get a realistic picture of what to expect. I still looked into other degree programs, though. In the end, law was simply the best fit for me.

Law and justice—they seem inseparable. And yet, Mr. Deppert, do you view the word “justice” with a certain degree of skepticism?

Dr. Armin Deppert: Because it’s too easily interpreted as a promise that the law simply cannot keep. We are required to apply the law to the best of our knowledge and belief, and we do so with the utmost seriousness. But whether this is ultimately perceived as fair by the individual is not entirely within our control. In civil law, strict neutrality applies: the parties must present their own case; we are not permitted to conduct our own investigation.

Claudia Schulz: If, for whatever reason, someone is unable to present their case properly, the outcome may seem unfair to them. They might have won if they had approached it differently. But we can only apply the law, and we must remain impartial. What I can say with conviction is this: My parents and I have never handed down a ruling where we felt that something wasn’t right. You have to be able to stand behind the decisions you make. You simply can’t act any other way.

It seems like work never really lets you go, even after hours—law isn't a nine-to-five job. Do you see that as a burden or an enrichment?

Claudia Schulz: It’s definitely enriching. If I’m out for a walk and an idea pops into my head about how to structure a case, I write it down. You can’t change who you are, and that’s a good thing. It shows that you’re truly engaged, that the work moves you. It never gets boring. Every case is different; every situation is new.

Dr. Armin Deppert: It’s always been that way for me, and the same goes for my wife. Sometimes you think you’ve seen it all, and then another case comes along that surprises you and opens up a new perspective. That’s actually the best part: this profession never stops challenging and captivating you.

Marietta Schulz: I haven’t gained any professional experience yet. But even as a student, I’m seeing how many different aspects are interconnected, how structured one’s thinking is, and yet how one always considers each individual case. I find that very exciting. I’m looking forward to putting my knowledge into practice later on.

Marietta, you are a recipient of a Deutschlandstipendium funded by the DZ Bank Foundation. What does this support mean to you, especially now, just before your first state examination?

Marietta Schulz: It’s more than just financial support. What really made me happy was the personal recognition: the award ceremony itself, but also the invitation to an event at DZ Bank. That gave me an interesting glimpse into a world I hadn’t known before, and I found that truly enriching. The university also offers a non-financial support program.

Mr. Deppert, what gave you the idea to establish the scholarship yourself? And what is your connection to the Association of Friends and Supporters of Goethe University?

Dr. Armin Deppert: It all started very simply: At a milestone birthday party, the host suggested to his guests that instead of giving gifts, they donate to the Deutschlandstipendium. I thought that was very sensible, because it makes a big difference. Incidentally, my wife herself was a scholarship recipient of the German National Academic Foundation. That also shaped our conviction that financial support is something important that should be passed on. I’ve been a member of the Friends and Supporters of Goethe University for quite some time. The university has remained important to me, even after so many years. Tina and I owe it a great deal. So does Claudia. And now Marietta. That creates a sense of obligation. You should be grateful for what you’ve received and give something back. A lot of things fall into place when you approach it that way.

Note: This text was translated using AI

 

The interview was conducted by Heike Jüngst