Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

Warning from the academic community: Increasing existing rents worsens the housing crisis and social displacement

Rising existing rents will worsen the housing crisis, more than 100 housing researchers make clear in a statement ahead of the German Jurists’ Conference.

Urban and housing researchers issue a joint statement on the legal assessment “Housing for All”

More than 100 scholars from interdisciplinary urban and housing research are taking a stand against a proposal from legal experts to align existing rents with new rental offers. Empirical findings from urban and housing research, in their view, contradict the assumption that such an increase would solve the housing crisis. On the contrary, it would make the crisis even worse, warn the researchers in their newly released joint statement, “Are rents too low?” With this, they challenge a legal assessment that will be discussed next week at the German Jurists’ Conference in Erfurt.

FRANKFURT/WEIMAR. The fact that existing rents and new rental offers have been diverging for years prompted legal scholars Markus Artz (University of Bielefeld) and Arnold Lehmann-Richter (Berlin School of Economics and Law) to propose lifting legal restrictions on increasing existing rents. Their assessment is a key basis for discussion at the 75th German Jurists’ Conference, taking place September 16–18, 2026, in Erfurt. There, in the Civil and Social Law section under the title “Housing for All,” reform proposals for rental housing law will be discussed, which are expected to lead to recommendations for lawmakers. The assessment picks up on the longstanding demand from the real estate and property management sector to reduce protections for tenants regarding rent levels – one of the major achievements of Germany’s ‘social rental law’ since 1971.

The newly published statement – initiated by scholars from the DFG Research Training Group “Habitual Change” at Goethe University Frankfurt and Bauhaus University Weimar, as well as the Leibniz Institute for Research on Society and Space (IRS) – offers a social science perspective on the empirical contexts and consequences, contrasting with the legal viewpoint. From the perspective of urban and housing research, the legal proposal is based on a mistaken assumption about the causes of the gap between new rental offers and existing rents.

“The proposal to raise existing rents, as set out in the assessment, is not a solution, but rather an aggravation of the housing crisis,” warns Matthias Bernt, adjunct professor at the Institute for Social Sciences at Humboldt University Berlin and acting head of the “Politics and Planning” research focus at the Leibniz Institute for Research on Society and Space (IRS). The widening gap is mainly due to a steadily increasing pressure for profit in Germany’s real estate markets, as well as the lack of enforcement of existing legal limits on rent increases for new rental offers (such as the rent cap).
“The increase in existing rents proposed in the assessment would not solve the housing crisis, but would further worsen its social, social policy, and fiscal consequences,” emphasizes Sebastian Schipper, professor of Urban Geography at Goethe University Frankfurt and co-spokesperson for the DFG Research Training Group “Habitual Change.” This would lead to a range of undesirable outcomes: overall rent increases, intensified social polarization in the housing market, a rise in housing-related poverty, higher public spending on accommodation allowances and housing costs (already more than 27 billion euros in 2025), and greater social segregation within cities.

Barbara Schönig, professor of Urban Planning at Bauhaus University Weimar and spokesperson for the Research Training Group, explains: “Raising existing rents would exclude even more people from the rental market.” Households with lower incomes and those with newer rental contracts would be especially burdened by high housing costs. Furthermore, the gap between existing rents and new rental offers reinforces the so-called lock-in effect, making it impossible for tenants to move and adapt their living space to their life situation. As a result, many remain in homes that are too large or too small, leading to more and more apartments being under- or over-occupied.

The statement underscores the need for socially responsible housing provision. From the signatories’ perspective, the dynamic of steadily rising new rental offers must be effectively stopped. Lisa Vollmer, academic staff member at IRS, points out: “The assessment contradicts social science analyses of housing policy and housing provision in many respects. Instead of raising existing rents, the solution lies in limiting new rental offers and finally enforcing existing laws consistently.” This would counteract spatial displacement and the lock-in effect. Lower new rental offers would improve affordability and access to housing for broad segments of the population.

The statement calls on members of the German Jurists’ Conference, legal scholars and policymakers, as well as the professional public, to recognize the extensive findings from interdisciplinary urban and housing research on the importance of stable rents for spatial and social integration in our cities and communities, and for social harmony in society.

Among the more than 100 signatories are researchers and practitioners in housing provision, including housing research experts such as Prof. Dr. Bernd Belina, PD Dr. Matthias Bernt, Prof. Dr. Christine Hannemann, Prof. Dr. Susanne Heeg, Dr. Andrej Holm, Prof. Dr. Stephan Lessenich, Prof. Dr. Sebastian Schipper, Prof. Dr. Barbara Schönig, and Dr. Lisa Vollmer.

Editor: Dr. Anke Sauter, Science Communication, PR & Communications Office, Theodor-W.-Adorno-Platz 1, 60323 Frankfurt, Tel. +49 (0)69 798-13066, [email protected]

Warning from the academic community