Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

Laschet Laugh: No Evidence of Influence on Voting Behavior

According to a new study, individual public missteps by politicians do not determine election outcomes. 

Recent study by the universities of Mainz and Frankfurt am Main on the impact of inappropriate emotional displays by political leaders

When chancellor candidate Armin Laschet laughed during a site visit after the 2021 flood disaster, it measurably damaged his public image. However, the scene, known as the “Laschet Laugh,” had no proven influence on voting behavior. This is the finding of a study by Prof. Constantin Wurthmann of Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz (JGU) and Dr. Jan Berz of Goethe University. The results from these political science researchers were published last week in the journal Electoral Studies.
The study began with the widely discussed scene from the 2021 federal election campaign: While the Federal President Frank-Walter Steinmeier spoke about the consequences of the disaster in the flood zone, then North Rhine-Westphalia Minister-President and CDU chancellor candidate Armin Laschet was seen laughing in the background. The images spread quickly and sparked intense criticism. “To this day, many believe that this moment may even have cost Laschet the election,” says Prof. Constantin Wurthmann, who has been Professor of Political Behavior and Representation at the University of Mainz since April 2026. “That’s why we wanted to find out what actually happens when political leaders show the wrong emotion at the wrong time.”

 

An unexpected event as a natural experiment  

According to Wurthmann, it is well established that voters respond positively to appropriate emotional displays from politicians. “But we know much less about the consequences of inappropriate displays ,” he explains. Such breaches of norms can certainly attract considerable media attention. “The key question, though, is whether damage to a person’s image ultimately changes people’s political behavior.” Thanks to a stroke of luck, this question could be examined particularly well using the Laschet Laugh: At the time of the event, a comprehensive panel survey on the 2021 federal election was already underway as part of the long-term study “German Longitudinal Election Study” by the German Society for Electoral Research and GESIS – Leibniz Institute for Social Sciences (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Wahlforschung and GESIS – Leibniz-Institut für Sozialwissenschaften). Some participants were surveyed just before the incident, while others provided their responses afterward. “In political science, this research design is called ‘Unexpected Event during Survey Design,’” says Dr. Jan Berz of Goethe University. “It allows us to study how an unexpected event influences attitudes and behavior.” Normally, it’s difficult to determine which effects during an election campaign are actually due to a single event and which are influenced by other factors. “But in this case, the timing of the survey gave us the opportunity to distinguish the effect of the incident from other campaign influences and to study a real political event,” Wurthmann notes.

Comparing data collected before and after the Laschet Laugh revealed a measurable personal image loss: respondents rated the chancellor candidate’s character more negatively afterward. “The effect was moderate but statistically significant,” says Wurthmann. However, the political scientists found no significant effect on voter turnout or voting decisions. “The damage to the person’s image is real, but limited, and does not translate into behavior.”

 

Viral moments don’t necessarily decide elections  

The study challenges the idea that single public missteps can determine an election campaign. “This example clearly shows that evaluating a person and making a voting decision are two different things,” says Wurthmann. “A moment like this can harm someone’s image without necessarily being decisive for the election.” According to the researchers, inappropriate emotional displays may have different effects than classic political scandals, such as those involving abuse of power or financial misconduct. Previous studies have documented effects for such cases that – unlike the Laschet Laugh – do extend beyond perceptions of the individual.