Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

Possibilities Beyond the University Professorship

A workshop report explores the development of academic career paths at universities in Germany.

How can a successful academic career be pursued beyond a professorship, and what obstacles might arise along the way? This question is becoming increasingly important. A key point of interest are the alternative career pathways developed by universities and the challenges they face in the course of doing so. In 2024, the Tenure-Track Network UniWinD initiated a series of eight interviews with eleven individuals actively driving the development and implementation of these concepts at their universities. Dr. Nicole Thaller, scientific advisor at Goethe University Frankfurt and a member of the network, is also a co-editor of the report. In response to the question of what criteria were used to select the participating universities, she says: “The universities interviewed were chosen because they are already actively developing and testing new models and represent a variety of higher education institutions in terms of size, age, and regional distribution across different federal states. The goal was to learn from the concrete institutional experiences – or ‘hands-on work’ – of universities that are already engaging with new HR and career structures, and to derive transferable findings that can be shared and made visible for other institutions,” she explains.

Germany’s Path Apart

In the introduction, the editors note that the German academic system is characterized by (multiple) fixed-term phases of academic qualification as preparation for a professorship, which is considered the primary career goal. If this is a “special path,” does that mean other countries have more permanent positions? “Yes, it’s often argued that Germany has a ‘path apart’ in international comparison,” Thaller explains: many years of fixed-term qualification positions – doctorate, postdoc, and an additional postdoc phase – with the professorship as virtually the only permanent position. In many other academic systems, however, more permanent or at least early tenure positions also exist below the level of professorship, she adds, pointing to positions like lecturer, research scientist, or assistant professor on a tenure track. This allows early career researchers to pursue an academic career path without the professorship being the only permanent option. Indeed, for most postdocs, the professorship is no longer the primary career goal, data from the 2023 Science Barometer indicate. But if the professorship continues to be the only real career option, does that create a dilemma? Or does the risk of brain drain remain, especially if people should choose to leave the academic system entirely? “Many postdocs want to remain in academia for the long term but don’t necessarily want to become professors,” Thaller says. Since German practice often offers the professorship as the only stable permanent position, this can result in a mismatch between individual career goals and institutional structures – leaving researchers in early career stages in a bind. “Some leave academia altogether, while others move abroad or transition to industry. Initial reforms, such as tenure-track programs, seek to alleviate the issue, but these structural changes are still ongoing.” The workshop report clearly shows that broad participation was considered important at the participating universities, which raises questions about the extent to which participatory involvement can also result in delays. “Participation is considered important since it often increases a reform’s legitimacy and acceptance. But it can also prolong processes. The different university interest groups – professors, non-professorial teaching staff, administration, students, etc. – sometimes have divergent interests, and decisions often have to pass multiple committees. When all these groups are involved, compromises need to be negotiated, which can lengthen consensus-driven decision-making processes,” Thaller explains. “The length of discussions is therefore viewed as a consequence of inclusion, but at the same time, it can lead to results that are better tailored to the specific institution and strengthen the sustainability of those outcomes.”

Verschiedene Handlungsfelder

Die Herausforderungen und Hürden für die Entwicklung alternativer Karrierewege sind unterschiedlich geartet. Ein wichtiges Handlungsfeld sind zunächst die rechtlichen Rahmenbedingungen. In Deutschland spielen etwa das Wissenschaftszeitvertragsgesetz und die jeweiligen Landeshochschulgesetze eine große Rolle. Sie legen fest, unter welchen Bedingungen wissenschaftliches Personal befristet oder unbefristet beschäftigt werden kann. „Wenn Universitäten neue Karrierewege jenseits der Professur entwickeln wollen, sollten diese Modelle somit in geltende arbeits- und beamtenrechtliche Vorgaben passen. Das kann, wie mehrere Interviewpartner*innen äußerten, für die Gestaltung neuer Stellenprofile durchaus herausfordernd sein“, betont Nicole Thaller. 

Ein zweiter Aspekt betrifft kapazitäre Fragen. Personalstrukturen stehen in Deutschland auch mit der Berechnung von Studienplatzkapazitäten in Verbindung. „Wenn Universitäten also neue Stellenprofile einführen – etwa stärker forschungsorientierte oder stärker lehrorientierte Positionen –, kann das Auswirkungen auf die Höhe der institutionellen Lehr- und Studienplatzkapazität haben. Solche Effekte sollten in der Planung mitgedacht werden“, empfiehlt Thaller. Hinzu kommen die finanziellen Rahmenbedingungen. Als Herausforderung wird in den Interviews des Werkstattberichts die begrenzte Grundfinanzierung der Universitäten benannt, die zudem Schwankungen und aktuell in vielen Bundesländern Kürzungen unterworfen sein kann. Dauerstellen wiederrum bedeuten eine langfristige Verpflichtung im universitären Haushalt, was die institutionelle Flexibili-tät reduzieren kann. „Viele Universitäten finanzieren daher in erheblichem Ausmaß über befristete Drittmittel Postdoc-Stellen, die damit ebenfalls häufig befristet sind. Entsprechende Anpassungen in den Verwendungsrichtlinien für Drittmittel könnten den Uni-versitäten hier mehr Spielraum verschaffen“, lautet die Einschätzung von Nicole Thaller.

Schließlich spielen aber auch fachkulturelle Unterschiede eine wichtige Rolle. Die Strukturen und Arbeitsweisen unterscheiden sich stark zwischen Disziplinen. Deshalb funktionieren neue Karrierewege nicht automatisch in allen Fächern gleich gut und müssen oft fachspezifisch angepasst werden. „Die Weiterentwicklung akademischer Karrierewege ist somit nicht nur eine Frage guter Konzepte, sondern sollte auch mit den jeweiligen Rahmenbedingungen abgestimmt werden.

Is a Cultural Shift Necessary?

One recurring theme in the workshop report is the need for a certain “cultural shift” at universities. What progress has been made to date? Does this “cultural shift” also mean that the expectations and demands of Early Career Researchers should not grow boundlessly and always be formulated with an eye on economic developments and universities’ capped budgets? “The ‘cultural shift’ mentioned in the workshop report primarily refers to a change in the traditional logic of academic careers at German universities. This goes beyond structural reforms – which would be needed for new job types – and extends to a redefined understanding of career paths, performance, and staff development,” explains Thaller.

Some trends are already starting to emerge, including the fact that tenure-track programs now address the topic of more predictable career paths. Universities are also discussing alternative career tracks such as researcher, lecturer, or science management paths. Topics like academic staff development and offerings such as mentoring or coaching are becoming more firmly embedded at an institutional level. “At the same time, expectations should remain realistic. Our interview partners pointed out that reforms take time, budgets are limited, and not every scholar can secure a permanent position. A successful cultural shift therefore requires a balanced interplay between institutional opportunities and the expectations of Early Career Researchers,” Thaller concludes.

 

Dirk Frank

Possibilities Beyond the University Professorship