Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

“A Responsibility to Contribute My Scholarly Perspective to the Ethics Council”

Prof. Rana Alsoufi

Jürgen Lecher

Prof. Rana Alsoufi in the Language and Cultural Studies Library (BSKW). 

 

Muslim theologian and Islamic studies scholar Rana Alsoufi has been appointed to the German Ethics Council by Bundestag President Julia Klöckner, effective April 1, 2026. UniReport spoke with Prof. Rana Alsoufi about her research, her approach to teaching, and what the appointment means to her.

 

UniReport: Prof. Alsoufi, what are you currently researching?

Rana Alsoufi: My current research focuses primarily on questions of Islamic legal theory and normative thought. One of my main areas of interest is the classical debate over how legal rulings are justified and the role of rational argument in the development of legal norms. I am particularly interested in how legal scholars justify their conclusions: How do they arrive at a legal ruling? What sources, methods of reasoning, and principles do they draw on? And to what extent can they transparently explain their understanding of the legislator’s intent? My work goes beyond reconstructing historical positions. I also examine how Islamic legal theory has engaged with concepts such as reason, textual interpretation, analogy, and ethical justification. The classical tradition of Islamic jurisprudence demonstrates that determining legal norms was never simply a matter of applying established rules. Rather, it involved a sophisticated process of methodological reasoning. In another ongoing project, I am exploring the relationship between ethical and legal norms within Islamic normative thought. The project examines whether, and how, moral norms can be distinguished from legal norms from a contemporary perspective. I am particularly interested in the arguments developed within Islamic theology and legal theory to differentiate between moral evaluation, religious obligation, and legal bindingness. My aim is to understand Islamic normative thought not merely as legal discourse, but as a broader framework for normative guidance.

 

What is particularly important to you in your teaching?

In my teaching, I want students to see Islamic theology as a vibrant academic discipline – one that has evolved over centuries, developed its own methods, concepts, and debates, and continues to offer important perspectives on contemporary questions. Students should not only become familiar with individual texts or scholarly positions, but also understand the historical, theological, and social contexts in which they emerged and the questions they sought to answer. I also encourage students not only to reconstruct Islamic theological traditions but to engage critically and thoughtfully with contemporary challenges. Questions surrounding religion, ethics, law, pluralism, and social cohesion have become increasingly pressing. Islamic theology can make a meaningful contribution to these debates by engaging rigorously with its own intellectual tradition while remaining open to present-day questions. A central aim of my teaching is to enable students to develop independent theological thinking. They should learn to connect tradition and the present in a methodologically sound way, rather than seeing them as opposing forces. Ultimately, I want to demonstrate that Islamic theology is not only concerned with preserving historical knowledge but also has an important role to play in contemporary ethical and societal debates.

 

Could you tell us about your upcoming projects?

One of my upcoming projects is titled “From Knowledge to Obligation: Analyzing Ethical Theories in Islamic Theology”. It examines how moral knowledge, value judgments, and normative obligations are justified within Islamic theology. The project explores questions about the relationship between reason and revelation, the role of human beings as knowing, acting, and morally responsible agents, and the basis on which moral judgments acquire normative force. Another project focuses on assisted suicide in medical ethics from an Islamic theological perspective. It examines how Islamic theological ethics defines the limits of individual self-determination in the face of suffering, human dignity, and the sanctity of life, as well as the normative responsibilities that society and the medical profession bear in preventing suicide.

 

What does your appointment to the German Ethics Council mean to you personally?

My appointment to the German Ethics Council means a great deal to me because I see it as both an honor and a significant responsibility. The Council addresses questions that are intellectually demanding while also having a direct impact on society. These are issues where different convictions, experiences, and interests come together and require careful ethical deliberation. I see my appointment not only as recognition of my academic work, but also as a responsibility to contribute my scholarly perspective to important public debates. Drawing on Islamic theology and ethics, I hope to enrich discussions by bringing an additional normative and religious perspective to the table. At the same time, I see my work on the Ethics Council as a contribution to democratic deliberation in a pluralistic society. Democracy depends on our ability to engage with difficult questions openly, respectfully, and through reasoned dialogue. The Ethics Council provides a forum in which academic, ideological, and societal perspectives come together and are considered collectively from an ethical perspective. To me, this represents an important effort to assume shared responsibility for society and to strengthen democratic understanding.

 

You conduct research on Islamic law and ethics. Is there a specifically Islamic perspective on the ethical questions addressed by the Ethics Council, or should we assume a diversity of views within Islamic scholarship?

The ethical questions addressed by the Ethics Council are rarely straightforward. They require careful reflection from a range of different perspectives. In many cases, fundamental ethical principles are at stake, and these can sometimes come into tension with one another – for example, autonomy, the protection of life, human dignity, justice, care, and responsibility. The real challenge lies in developing criteria for responsible ethical deliberation: Which principle deserves particular protection in a given situation? Who bears moral responsibility? And under what conditions can a decision be regarded as ethically justified? From an Islamic theological perspective, I would not speak of a single Islamic viewpoint. Islamic theology, particularly in systematic theology and normative thought, encompasses a wide range of positions, methods of reasoning, and intellectual priorities. This diversity reflects differences in the questions being addressed, the sources consulted, the methodological approaches adopted, and the legal and theological traditions involved. At the same time, this diversity does not mean that Islamic perspectives are arbitrary. They are grounded in shared normative principles, including the protection of life, human dignity, accountability before God, human moral agency, and the relationship between individual decision-making and social responsibility. It is precisely this interaction between theological, ethical, and legal reasoning that makes Islamic normative thought particularly relevant to contemporary ethical debates.

 

Can you give examples of how current ethical questions are being discussed within the Islamic community, perhaps in dialogue with other religions?

Many of today’s ethical questions are discussed within the Islamic community in the context of medical ethics – for example, decisions about limiting treatment, euthanasia, assisted suicide, and responses to severe suffering. These discussions do not take place solely within the Islamic tradition. They also involve dialogue with Jewish and Christian scholars who are grappling with similar normative questions. Medical ethics clearly illustrates that Jewish, Christian, and Islamic traditions often confront comparable challenges, including the protection of life, the preservation of human dignity, the ethical significance of suffering, and the limits of individual self-determination.

 

How important are interfaith and interdisciplinary perspectives to your research?

Interfaith and interdisciplinary perspectives are central to both my research and my teaching. Many ethical questions – particularly in medical ethics – cannot be adequately addressed from a single disciplinary or religious perspective. That is why engaging with theological, philosophical, legal, and medical perspectives is an essential part of my work.

 

Questions: Dirk Frank