Women in Literary Criticism during the Enlightenment and Romanticism: A Conference Report
The literary critic, as an authority in evaluating literary work, has historically and contemporarily been predominantly understood as male. The conference “Invisible Judgments,” held in early March at Goethe University Frankfurt, sought to critically examine this predominant narrative of literary criticism as a male-dominated domain and to raise awareness of women in literary criticism. The starting point for the conference was the Federal Ministry of Research, Technology and Space (BMFTR) research project “Lost in Archives,” embedded in the “Innovative Frauen im Fokus” (IFiF, Innovative Women in Focus) funding program, led by organizers Marília Jöhnk and Grace Evans since October 2024. Across 16 presentations, the speakers highlighted examples of women in literary criticism from Germany, France, Colombia, Argentina, Romania, and England, clearly demonstrating that literary criticism during the Enlightenment and Romanticism was also a sphere for women. Furthermore, transnational connections emerged, enriched by insights into contemporary female critics and the Digital Humanities.
Another key theme was the often-political dimension of literary criticism. The reasons behind the invisibility of women in literary criticism were explored through systemic approaches – textual examples made it unequivocally clear that the women discussed were not lacking in judgment or the sharp tongue often associated with critics. Several key questions emerged from the presentations and discussions: How do we define literary criticism? Does a narrow definition of literary criticism, as is particularly prevalent in Germany, contribute to the invisibility of women in this field? How can we preserve visibility for women in literary criticism? And how can these critical voices be sustainably amplified? What role do research opportunities and data collections play in this process?
With the help of the interphilological contributions, the conference was able to establish an important beginning for a historical research exchange on female literary critics. The results of this conference, as well as other relevant research results from the “Lost in Archives” subproject on literary criticism, will be published in an open-access conference volume next year by transcript. The conference was funded by the Fritz Thyssen Foundation.
Deborah Segger, student assistant in the Lost in Archives project