Severe overweight and obesity have become a global pandemic. But what drives our strong cravings for unhealthy foods? Neuropsychologist Dana M. Small, this year’s Friedrich Merz visiting professor, is working to answer that question.
“No one can escape them. Energy-dense foods, far too sweet and full of unhealthy fats, are everywhere. For decades, these modern eating habits have been taking a toll on our bodies.” So begins the film “Our Brain Is What It Eats”, which will be screened in November at a public symposium held as part of the Friedrich Merz Visiting Professorship of Prof. Dana Small. A psychologist at McGill University in Montreal, she is a leading researcher in obesity – a disease that affects millions of people worldwide. In Germany, nearly one in five adults has obesity, and the trend is rising. The number of people affected worldwide has more than doubled since 1990, and among children and adolescents it has quadrupled. Obesity is a global problem that affects every region and social group, albeit to varying degrees.
Obesity is also a major driver of more than 200 related diseases. In Germany alone, Type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease and various cancers associated with severe overweight are linked to about €50 billion in annual costs, posing a major challenge for the healthcare system. The societal importance of this global health crisis is reflected in policy decisions. Drugs intended to help people with obesity lose weight by reducing hunger have now been approved in Europe. Alongside these “weight-loss shots,” a “sugar tax” is also the subject of heated debate. The proposed tax is intended both to change consumers’ purchasing habits and to encourage manufacturers to reduce the amount of sugar in their products.
The Brain Favors Reliable Sources of Energy
All these approaches, however, are based on the idea that excess weight is primarily the result of a lack of willpower. New research suggests that this view is too simplistic, and Dana Small has made an important contribution to changing it. “I’m interested in how information from the external and internal worlds is integrated to shape our decisions about what to eat. As a neuropsychologist, I also want to understand the relationship between metabolic disorders and brain health,” she explains. Her work focuses on the brain’s reward system, which helps explain why we can find it so hard to stop eating certain foods. Small has adapted and expanded the classic “food reward” hypothesis, which holds that the pleasure of eating activates the brain’s reward system and motivates us to eat more, by incorporating information about what is happening inside the body, known as interoceptive signals.
Her theory is that food is not rewarding simply because of its taste or calorie content. Rather, the gut signals to the brain how effectively it has converted the nutrients we consume into usable energy. Under this hypothesis, foods are valued when they provide energy reliably. “The most important new finding is that the key trigger for food’s rewarding effect is not tied to eating itself, but rather to digestion. In other words, the signals generated as nutrients are digested and processed are both necessary and sufficient to produce reinforcement or learning through reward. This has implications for models of reinforcement learning, which have traditionally paid little attention to signals from inside the body,” the psychologist says.
The Brain Has to Unlearn
According to a study from Small’s lab using advanced neuroimaging techniques, the brain’s reward system responds especially strongly to foods combining fat with rapidly available carbohydrates such as glucose. This combination is common in highly processed foods. Small’s hypothesis helps explain why these products can be so difficult to resist: Part of the reward system operates below the level of conscious awareness. At the same time, this understanding may open new avenues for treatments that go beyond conventional diets. Future medications could influence the brain’s reward and motivation systems, reducing the reward response associated with anticipating food. Rather than reducing patients’ hunger, as weight-loss shots do, these medications would change what the brain has learned about food.
Small has also developed a test that can predict, with some degree of accuracy, whether someone is likely to lose weight through a behavioral treatment considered the gold standard. “Participants who did well on the cognitive task lost 10% of their body weight. Those who did poorly on the task, by contrast, lost no weight at all,” Small explains. The next step would be to use the test in a clinical trial to see whether it can predict treatment outcomes. “If our finding is confirmed, this could be a useful tool for deciding which treatment is right for a particular person, as part of a personalized precision-medicine approach.”
Making Obesity Visible as a Multidimensional Disease
Dana Small is coming to Frankfurt at the invitation of two researchers from Goethe University’s Medical Center. PD Dr. Sharmili Edwin Thanarajah leads the Dr. Elmar and Ellis Reiss Center for Metabolic Psychiatry at the Clinic for Psychiatry, Psychosomatics and Psychotherapy, where her work focuses on the links between obesity, diabetes and mental health. Prof. Dr. Jörg Bojunga heads the Endocrinology, Diabetology and Nutritional Medicine unit in Medical Clinic I. The two guest curators aim to raise awareness of obesity as a chronic, multidimensional disease. Their plans include establishing interdisciplinary metabolic medicine and creating a Metabolic Unit. Small’s research supports this view of obesity as a neurobiological disease. “Her work has been pivotal in showing how peripheral metabolic signals, reward processes and sensory processing are integrated in the brain to shape eating behavior, energy intake and body weight,” the two guest curators wrote in their nomination.
The Frankfurt team hopes the visiting professorship will strengthen research into obesity and metabolism, as well as systems neuroscience. “Dana Small’s expertise offers excellent opportunities for interdisciplinary collaboration and will further raise Goethe University’s international profile,” the curators say. Dana Small is also looking forward to her time in Frankfurt: “I have great respect for the scientific community in Germany. I’m looking forward to engaging discussions and to building new collaborations and professional connections.”
Larissa Tetsch

Dana M. Small

Dana M. Small