South African historian Esté Kotzé recently spent time as a research fellow at the Forschungskolleg Humanwissenschaften Institute of Advanced Studies. She was invited by Xenia von Tippelskirch, professor of the history of religious dynamics at Goethe University Frankfurt and director of the Frankfurt-based Institut franco-allemand de sciences historiques et sociales (IFRA-SHS), and the “Religion and De:Toxification” (RelTox) research group.
Kotzé studies how the Dutch Reformed Church (DRC) in South Africa understood poverty and poor relief at different points in the country’s history. “I’m especially interested in how these ideas were shaped more by broader social and political developments than by the theological foundations of Calvinist charity,” she says. Her research focuses on two periods: the 18th century at the Cape under the Dutch East India Company (VOC), and the 1920s and 1930s, when Afrikaner nationalism gained influence in the decades before apartheid was formally introduced in 1948. Kotzé explains what connects these otherwise very different periods: “Both were marked by complex relationships between church and state, reflected in changing social and political ideas about poverty and race. I’m particularly interested in how charitable measures, initially justified on religious and moral grounds, gradually became part of broader projects of social control and welfare policy, as well as racist efforts to promote or segregate particular groups.”
During the 18th century, for example, the VOC exerted considerable influence over public and religious life at the Cape, including church finances and poor relief. Access to assistance therefore depended on religious affiliation and economic class, as well as on the racial hierarchies that gradually hardened over the course of the century. By the early 20th century, the so-called “Poor White” problem had become a growing concern. “In the context of emerging Afrikaner nationalism, white poverty was seen not only by politicians and church leaders as an economic problem, but also as a threat to the moral and social future of ‘white’ South Africa. In the 1920s and 1930s, the DRC developed a closer partnership with the state and pursued welfare more systematically, even ‘scientifically,’ shaped by Afrikaner nationalist thought. In short, the DRC’s changing approach to poverty was closely connected to changing ideas about race, gender and social belonging,” Kotzé says.
During her fellowship at Forschungskolleg Humanwissenschaften, Kotzé has focused in particular on the Luckhoff Institute (later renamed the Durbanville Institute for Girls), which the DRC ran from 1925 to 1936. The case study, she says, offers a revealing example of the intersections between church, state and ideas about race. “The institute aimed to take poor, delinquent white girls into its care and educate them to become what the DRC considered useful members of Afrikaner society. Their education combined Christian ideals with practical training and a strongly gendered vision of their future roles as wives and mothers of the Afrikaner people,” Kotzé says. “As my research continues, I hope to show that the history of church charity, a relatively understudied field in South African history, can offer important insights into the long-term historical roots of South Africa’s welfare system. I also want to examine how racialized and gendered ideas of ‘worthiness’ shaped social inclusion and exclusion long before apartheid was formally introduced.”
What role does postcolonial discourse play for a historian studying a country with a colonial past? Has it raised new research questions, and has it changed how she sees herself as a historian? “South African historiography has, of course, been profoundly shaped by the historical experience of colonialism, slavery and apartheid. This history has led historians to consider whose voices have traditionally been heard in historical discourse, whose have been marginalized, and how the legacies of colonial and apartheid-era institutions continue to shape the way we write history. This reflection is an essential part of critically examining how historical knowledge is produced,” Kotzé says. It means, she explains, asking questions about the sources we use, the categories we choose and the perspectives that may be missing from the archive. It is equally important to pay attention to the institutional and intellectual contexts in which historical knowledge was produced. South African historians have long grappled with fundamental questions about slavery, colonialism and apartheid. “But I think one of the most productive developments has been a growing willingness to question the practice of history itself. Rather than simply replacing one dominant narrative with another, we should ask how different, sometimes competing experiences can be brought into conversation. This is especially relevant to my own research, which focuses on the colonial period and the decades before apartheid, as well as on settler communities and their descendants. Postcolonial approaches have encouraged me to ask new questions about these communities: not only how they experienced historical events, but also how their identities, institutions and ideas about society were shaped in relation to colonial power and to people excluded by those structures. That requires me to look beyond the dominant voices in my sources and consider what their silences might tell us.”
How does Kotzé look back on her time at Forschungskolleg Humanwissenschaften, and what has she found especially rewarding? “The combination of the Institute’s supportive environment, time to focus on my work and, above all, the people I’ve met here has made the fellowship an especially enriching experience. It has not only allowed me to advance my research but also reminded me how important intellectual exchange and collegial conversation are to academic work, something that is often lost in increasingly siloed university structures.”
Dirk Frank

Esté Kotzé

Esté Kotzé