From the Vatican Archives to New France, historian and Marie Curie fellow Dr. Isabel Harvey has followed an expanding cast of overlooked historical actors. Her latest research adds perhaps the most uncontrollable of them all: the environment.
Maybe it is no coincidence that the Zoom conversation with Dr. Isabel Harvey takes place on a day when the temperature in her apartment has reached a staggering 38 degrees Celsius. The climate, it seems, is demonstrating one of the central ideas behind her latest research: environments shape behavior. They force people to adapt, abandon plans and rethink assumptions.
The Catholic missionaries Harvey studies learned much the same lesson when they travelled across the Atlantic to New France. Arriving with ideas about how communities should be organized and Catholicism practiced, they encountered vast distances, unfamiliar landscapes and winters unlike anything most had experienced in Europe. Climate and geography did not simply provide the backdrop to their missionary work. They helped determine what was possible.
That is the premise behind “MissNature – The Evangelizing Missions facing the Nature: Situated Knowledge and Environmental Impacts of Catholic Church in New France, France and Southern Italy during the Early Modern Period”, Harvey’s current postdoctoral research project at Goethe University Frankfurt and the Franco-German Institute for Historical and Social Sciences (IFRA-SHS).
It is also the latest step in a research journey that began somewhere rather different: with women, convents and thousands of letters buried in the Vatican archives.
The Women Missing From History
Harvey describes herself first and foremost as a historian of the Catholic Church. “I feel like I was born as a historian of the Catholic Church and remain one to this day,” she says. “I am also a historian of subaltern groups, including women.” Her fascination lies not only with religion itself, but with the Church as an institution: a system that has existed for close to two millennia, developed rules and structures spanning continents, and continually renegotiated its relationship with the people living within and around it.
That interest already shaped Harvey’s doctoral research at McGill University, which dealt with the question of what it means to be embodied as a woman in the Catholic Church. To understand more about how women interacted with that system, Harvey spent years working in the archives of the Holy See. Much of the material she encountered had barely been scientifically examined and often came without an index. “I think I must have copied more than 5,000 letters,” she recalls. “I practically adopted a monastic lifestyle myself while I was researching.”
Only a few of the documents were written by or about saints, heretics or famous figures. Instead, many of the letters addressed remarkably ordinary problems. Women wrote to Rome asking whether property should be sold or money taken from a dowry fund to rebuild a convent wall after an earthquake, or seeking advice about how to organize a convent garden. “Many of these letters came from normal women like you and me, who turned to the higher authority to help solve everyday issues.”
For Harvey, those letters opened another historical world. Italy in the 16th and 17th centuries consisted of a patchwork of states and communities; many small convents existed in towns far removed from the large religious institutions that dominate much of the historical record. Yet comparatively little was known about the women inhabiting them – or about the many women pursuing religious lives outside conventional cloistered orders. The more Harvey looked at the relationship between these women and Rome, the more her perspective widened.
When Rome Meets the World
During subsequent postdoctoral research, including at UCLouvain under Professor Silvia Mostaccio, Harvey increasingly examined forms of female Catholic religious life beyond conventional convent structures. From there, another question emerged: if individuals and communities were continually reaching out to Rome, how did Rome reach out to the rest of the world? “Looking at missionary activities became the next logical step,” she says.
The shift expanded both Harvey’s geography and her cast of historical protagonists. Alongside women and other less privileged groups, missionaries, missioned communities and Indigenous peoples living in colonial and non-European settings increasingly came into focus.
And then another actor entered the picture: The environment.
“The land the missionaries found shaped their activities,” Harvey says. That idea sits at the heart of MissNature. Its title deliberately plays with several meanings: missionary activity, attempts to control nature, and the ways in which the Church could “miss” nature by failing to adequately account for it in its apostolic ambitions. The project examines missionary activity in New France, France and southern Italy and asks what happens when religious ideas that claim universal validity encounter very specific environments.
Mapping as an act of ordering. The Roman Jesuit Francesco Giuseppe Bressani (1612–1672) arrived in New France in 1642, traveled deep inland, where he lived and preached among the Wendat. In 1644, he was taken captive by the Mohawk. His 1657 map draws on those firsthand experiences, pairing a remarkably accurate representation of the Great Lakes region with a distinctly European, Jesuit missionary gaze. Indigenous people, animals and landscapes are carefully observed and depicted, yet they are simultaneously translated through mapping, naming and Christian imagery into European spatial, cultural and religious frameworks. Attributed to Francesco Giuseppe Bressani SJ, Novae Franciae accurata delineatio, 1657. Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division, G3400 1657.B7.
Harvey herself brings a particular familiarity with one of those extremes. A native Quebecer, she grew up in northern Canada, in a family whose members worked the region’s mines. She was the first to attend university. Further north from her hometown lie predominantly Indigenous territories. The contrast between the 38-degree heat of her flat in Rome and the minus-40-degree winters she remembers from Quebec is extreme, and illustrates a deceptively simple historical question: what happens to universal ideas when they encounter local realities?
A Protagonist You Cannot Excommunicate
For Catholic missionaries arriving in New France, the challenge went far beyond cold weather. European models of missionary settlement imagined a parish organized around a church, surrounded by a relatively stable agricultural community. But such assumptions did not necessarily correspond to the societies missionaries encountered. Indigenous communities had their own patterns of movement, hunting, fishing and agriculture, developed in response to their environments. Missionaries could attempt to change those practices. But they could not simply change the landscape or climate in which they operated.
For Harvey, this makes the environment more than scenery in the historical narrative. It becomes a protagonist in its own right. “My historical work has always taken a systemic approach; I try to understand the system in which individuals are operating,” she explains. “With this historiographical background, I drew up a corresponding ecosystemic approach that systematically includes the environment into whatever system I am studying.”
To observe is also to categorize. The Silesian Jesuit Florian Paucke (1719–1780) arrived in South America in 1749 and spent many years missioning among the Mocoví in what is now Argentina. After returning to Europe, he compiled “Hin und Her”, a record of the plants, animals and ways of life he had encountered. His late-18th-century depiction of pumpkins and melons pairs careful firsthand observation with a distinctly European and Jesuit missionary perspective. Local nature is described, compared and classified, while terms such as Zapallos and Calabazas reveal the process of translation itself: an unfamiliar environment is rendered legible through European categories and the language of the colonial and Christian systems of knowledge. Image: Florian Paucke SJ, “Zapallos” and “calabazas,” from Hin und Her, 18th c.
Nature could determine where settlements were possible, which foods were available, how people moved and whether European agricultural practices could be transferred to a new continent –constraints that, in turn, affected missionary strategies. More than that: They could even challenge assumptions about providence. Many missionaries, Harvey says, arrived believing that their mission formed part of a divine project and that their needs would somehow be provided for. Once confronted with enormous distances, unfamiliar food systems, severe weather and communities organized according to very different principles, those expectations collided with reality. The universal ambitions of the Church had to be negotiated locally.
This leads Harvey to one of the larger hypotheses she is exploring: whether centuries of encounters with non-Christian societies and environments contributed, over the very long term, to changes in the Church’s understanding of universality itself. Rather than defining universality exclusively through the conversion of humanity to Catholicism, the modern Church increasingly came to emphasize dialogue and coexistence among Christian denominations and religions. Harvey sees the ecumenical and interreligious orientation associated with the Second Vatican Council of the 1960s as part of a much longer historical development.
Underlying many of these encounters, she argues, is a question that has followed her throughout her research: control. Whether the Church was establishing rules governing life in a small European convent or sending missionaries across the Atlantic, it sought to create structures through which religious life could be ordered.
But nature presents a particular problem for systems built around rules. “The environment is maybe the strongest uncontrollable element because you cannot punish or excommunicate it. It simply is.”
Thinking in Systems
Over almost a decade of postdoctoral research, Harvey has repeatedly widened the systems she examines. MissNature is her fifth postdoc and her second in Germany. Her academic trajectory has taken her from her doctorate at McGill University to research positions at Humboldt University Berlin, Ca’ Foscari University of Venice, Université du Québec à Montréal and UCLouvain before bringing her to Frankfurt.
A consistent thread running through those projects is Catholicism. Another is Harvey’s interest in the structures that shape people’s lives – a perspective closely connected to feminism. She describes herself as an avid feminist and supporter of the women’s movement but says her central question has always gone beyond identifying inequality. She wants to understand the structures that produce it. “To me it’s more than just politics, social relations and discourse. It’s the system that allows these to arise in the first place.”
This underlying conviction is also reflected in Harvey’s preference for collaborative research. “I rarely work alone; all my projects are cooperative.” Rather than trying to become an expert in every field her questions touch upon, she builds research structures that bring different forms of expertise together.
One of the largest is Sorores, an international project examining non-cloistered religious women in medieval and early modern Europe. Coordinated by Harvey together with historians Sylvie Duval and Sergi Sancho Fibla, the project challenges a historiography largely built around Church-defined categories of female religious life and seeks to recover the much more diverse communities and individual women who pursued religious vocations beyond the convent.
“Sorores not only taught me how to manage collective projects successfully and organize a series of conferences in France, Italy, Spain, Canada and the US,” Harvey says. “It launched my career.”
That collaborative model has since expanded with Harvey’s questions. Her more recent network PANEM – Pratiques Alimentaires Négociées dans les Écosystèmes Missionnaires, established with Thomas Brignon and Fiona Karcz, brings together around 35 scholars examining food practices within missionary ecosystems and the interactions between missionaries, Indigenous populations and their environments.
As the questions increasingly cross disciplinary boundaries, so does the expertise Harvey draws on. She has worked with theologians and linguists and recently began collaborating with paleoecologists in Montreal. Evidence preserved in the soil can reveal patterns of agriculture, human settlement and livestock that written sources alone cannot provide. “The insights we gain here are a wonderful complement.”
There is another reason Harvey’s research interests keep expanding: one question tends to generate the next. “That is one of my biggest flaws,” she says, laughing. “I have a hard time finishing things. I reach the stage of being 80-90% done, and have developed an answer in my mind, which immediately takes me to the next question I want to explore.”
Her inherently collaborative approach also helps explain Harvey’s return to Germany. She first met Goethe University historian Professor Xenia con Tippelskirch, now director of IFRA-SHS, nearly two decades ago, when Harvey was completing her MA and von Tippelskirch was a Marie Curie Postdoctoral Fellow at EHESS in Paris. Years later, after Harvey had completed her doctorate, their shared research interests brought her to Humboldt University Berlin, where von Tippelskirch ended up supervising her first postdoc. Their academic paths subsequently diverged, but the connection remained.
“I admire Xenia as a person and as a scholar,” Harvey says. “I think she is the longest academic relationship I have had in my life. We have known each other for close to 20 years now, and I could not have asked for a better mentor or sparring partner.” Today, the two also describe each other as friends.

Dr. Isabel Harvey: “The land the missionaries encountered shaped their work.” Her project, MissNature, examines missionary activity in New France, France and southern Italy - asking how universal religious claims collide with particular environments.

Dr. Isabel Harvey: “The land the missionaries encountered shaped their work.” Her project, MissNature, examines missionary activity in New France, France and southern Italy - asking how universal religious claims collide with particular environments.
From Past to Present
Despite all the centuries separating Harvey’s historical subjects from the present, she sees striking continuities in the questions they raise. Climate change, migration and encounters between societies with very different ways of understanding the world may feel uniquely contemporary. Harvey’s research suggests otherwise. “My work shows that the crises we are experiencing right now, including the challenges associated with them, are not really new.”
Missionaries arriving in unfamiliar environments were confronted with people whose languages, religious beliefs, food systems and relationships with the land differed radically from their own. Yet they were also dependent on those communities for knowledge and, in some cases, survival. That dependence placed limits on the missionaries’ ability simply to impose their own systems. They had to observe, negotiate and adapt.
Perhaps that explains why the Catholic Church continues to fascinate her. Its influence has diminished dramatically in places such as her native Quebec, where the Quiet Revolution of the 1960s brought rapid secularization. Yet Catholicism remains both an institution of extraordinary longevity. “Faith exists and continues to be a key part of many people’s lives,” Harvey says. “For a system to survive 2,000 years, it must be deemed worthy by a great many people.”
Understanding such a system means looking not only at the people who wield authority within it, but at those who live at its edges, negotiate its rules or force it to adapt. Harvey began by looking for women whose lives had largely disappeared from conventional histories of the Church. Following them led her outward: from convents to Rome, from Rome to missionary worlds, and eventually from people to the environments in which all of them lived.
And there, perhaps, she encountered the ultimate limit to institutional control: People can be instructed, converted, disciplined or excommunicated. The weather cannot.
Leonie Schultens