Skip to main content
Logo of Goethe university

“People Often Find the Law Inaccessible”

Ronen Steinke, a journalist and editor at Süddeutsche Zeitung, legal scholar and adjunct instructor at Goethe University Frankfurt, talks with UniReport about shortcomings in the rule of law and the justice system, among others.

 

UniReport: Mr. Steinke, let’s start with a current debate. After the attack at this year’s Berlin’s Pride event, Germany’s interior minister said that adult criminal law should also apply to young adults classified as potential threats. What’s your view? Is there a need, or a legal basis, to change the law in this area? Should the state respond to attacks like this by changing the law?

Ronen Steinke: No one wants to feel powerless in the face of horrific violence like the attack at Berlin’s Pride event. That is why, after moments like these, politicians are often expected to strike a certain pose, to put on a display of action and resolve. The government is supposed to project the opposite of uncertainty: determination, decisiveness, a tough response to terror. While I can understand that impulse psychologically, any law hastily passed in response to a terrorist attack also carries an uncomfortable implication: that the rule of law failed to address the problem and is somehow partly to blame. Of course, that is nonsense – the only one responsible are the perpetrators. The idea of imposing harsher legal penalties on people deemed potential threats does not get us anywhere. What does “potential threat” even mean? It describes people the police believe might commit crimes in the future – something that cannot be proven. We are talking here about a prediction, and one that, if someone is innocent, cannot be disproven. A term like that has little place in a courtroom.

 

What legal topics do you cover in your teaching?

It is important to me that we talk more about German history in law school. Lawyers played a shameful role under the Nazis and in the East German dictatorship. What good is the most elegant legal reasoning if it can just as easily be used to carry out a genocide? For a long time, law faculties also said little about the Nazi-era continuities in Germany’s legal system. Several committed professors are now working to change that. I do my part, including by organizing a regular lecture series with Andrea Kießling, a scholar of administrative law, and Matthias Jahn, a criminal law scholar. I also teach intensive seminars on criminal law, including one coming up on recent developments in offenses involving speech, like hate speech, for instance.

 

Could the public use a clearer explanation of the law? Like other academic fields, is law often hard for nonspecialists to understand?

I agree with you: People often find the law inaccessible. Many who encounter a legal problem or go through a court proceeding feel powerless. I think that is a very serious issue. It diminishes people. But the fault does not lie with them. As citizens, we should be able to expect the state to explain clearly what rules it sets and what behavior it expects. Of course, every field has its own terminology – that is true of law just as it is of medicine. However, if two surgeons performing a procedure talk to each other in language their patient cannot understand, that may be tolerable. The patient is under anesthesia, after all. In a courtroom, however, if the professionals speak in a way that leaves a defendant no chance to join the conversation, challenge what is being said or actively exercise their rights, that is not acceptable. One thing we teach in law school is that a defendant is not merely a passive object of the proceedings, but a participant with rights who must be treated with respect. In practice, that principle is often undermined, beginning with the language used in court.

 

Your books have examined some of the shortcomings of the rule of law and the justice system. In “Vor dem Gesetz sind nicht alle Gleich” [Not Everyone Is Equal Before the Law], for example, you argue that defendants without money have far less ability to exercise their rights than those who can afford to. Do you discuss this in your seminars? Do law students respond to the argument with empathy and agreement?

We recently held a seminar on criminal law and social inequality. The students produced some truly outstanding and sharply critical work. In Germany, for example, about 90% of defendants in local courts have no lawyer. They cannot afford one, so they have to represent themselves, often overwhelmed and afraid. Under current law, they are not entitled to state assistance. Court-appointed counsel is available only in very few cases. My sense is that younger students can readily see that this system cannot be fair. How is a homeless person, or someone who has not completed school, supposed to defend themselves when they do not know, and cannot be expected to know, all the unwritten rules of a courtroom? The problem in Germany, as I see it, is that many older legal professionals lose sight of issues like this or grow accustomed to them.

 

In recent years, universities have seen increasingly heated debate about academic freedom and threats to it, including how academic freedom relates to freedom of opinion and expression more broadly. You’ve also voiced concern about the increasingly narrow limits on what can legally be said in Germany. Do you also see academic freedom as being under threat?

I know of no bans on researching particular subjects. In addition to being willing, people also need to have the courage to exercise their academic freedom. In recent years, we have seen many cases of universities canceling talks on their own initiative, or even disinviting visiting professors, because they feared controversy. That is intellectually impoverished. Academic freedom can also wither through voluntary self-censorship. Some university leaders seem to care more about quiet hallways and students earning their credits than about making the university a place for intellectual debate.

 

You have also written extensively about antisemitism in Germany, in books such as “Terror Against Jews” and “Antisemitism in Language”. How do you see the debate on campuses, especially since October 7, 2023?

It has become a debate about Israel. I am baffled by how many people now portray Israel, a refuge for many Jews driven from their homes, including from Arab countries, as a “white colonial state.” I am also baffled by how selectively people in Germany engage with international law. They invoke it only when it suits their preferred narrative.
 

Interview: Dirk Frank

Ronen Steinke

Ronen Steinke

Friedrich Bungert